Tenney's Pizza AF/E. Lehi/Highland

933 W 500 N #3763, American Fork
(801) 772-0111

Recent Reviews

Patricia Wayne

The prices has gone up alot, if you have a small family, it is a great place, but I have a large family and 80$ for pizza is alot. I don't know if I will go there again, even though I like the pizza.

Mat Bickley

The Best Cauliflower Crust hands down on Utah! Super friendly staff as well and make the food quick when you order!Only suggestion is to bring back the Real Dill Pizza!

Josh “Lookatmenow” Ess

Wasn't expecting much, was rather surprised, tasty affordable pizza

Matt B

Make no mistake, this isn’t any better than Little Caesars in quality, but double the price. I ordered the pan crust and was given a flat overcooked bland crust.

Mike Craggett

Like Chuck E Cheese pizza but worse if you can believe that. The dough is very undercooked and there is hardly any sauce plus there is zero flavor. It literally tastes like cardboard. Not kidding!!!

Kevin Jennings Jr

A couple friends and I tried this place on a recommendation from a local. They mentioned a 24" pizza called "The Beast", so of course we had to try it. It was absolutly huge and worth trying once but the taste just wasn't there for any of us to keep coming back.

Holly SJ

I've always loved Tenneys pizza but I love them even more now.. why because of the pickle pizza.. its so so so so so very delicious!! I absolutely LOVE IT!! it's my new very favorite pizza topping.. yummmm

Chris Melville

I give this a 3 with the hopes that it improves. It has way to high of a rating for the quality of this pizza. It’s not terrible. But not what I was expecting when I saw how many stars they had. Just trying to help others

Jerry Winkel

I'm not sure why they thought this pizza was ok to put in the box. Burnt to a crisp.

Berni

Wonderful pizza and great prices! We highly recommend Tenny's

Jennica Larsen

Waited the fifteen minute wait they told us it would be, at the 15 minute mark a worker came and told us it would be a twenty minute wait. We could see them goofing around with each other in the back, not doing anything, even though they had already taken our order and knew we were here. I guess this is what happens when only 14 year olds work in a pizza place with no adults?‍♀️

Char Smith

Not to impressed the pizza was really doughing bread steaks were burnt won’t eat there again called to talk to the manger or someone but no Anwser

Jeff Hostetler

I love this place! I snuck in at 9:45 and the kind young woman working whipped up a pepperoni pizza for me before closing! Thank you!

Isaac Taylor

Service was decent and my order was ready when I arrived to pick it up, but the pizza is about as good as you would expect from a place where the best slogan they could come up with is "making pizza great again". Ingredients are bottom of the barrel quality and it certainly shows in the bland, carelessly thrown together food. Doesn't help that I got the runs for a day after.

SherRon Marcek

Love this pizza place. The pricing is fair and the food is tasty. Highly recommend the cheese bread! - One time we had a bad experience and the manager called to make it right.

Load More

Tenney's Pizza AF/E. Lehi/Highland

933 W 500 N #3763, American Fork, UT 84003
(801) 772-0111