Gaetano's Sub Shop

1618 S State St, Salt Lake City
(801) 467-3676

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Anthony Alcox

One of the best sandwiches I’ve had, will be going back. Also, the lady up front (wish I got her name) was super nice and made the experience great helping me decide what to get as a first-timer. (Went with Italian)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Michael Harrison

Sadly the quality of their food has really gone downhill. Been going there for years but the last couple times has been bad enough I didn’t finish my sandwich. Now I know!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 3

Race Oldham

Quick, Great food. Have yet to find a sandwich that wasn't good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicago Dog, Cheese Steak, French Fries

T.J. O

I come here often for lunch during the week. I've only ever had the Philly, but it's pretty good.

The bread is soft and fresh and the meat and toppings great as well. I've had one or two times the meat tasted a little over cooked, but that's not the norm. Usually very good.

Almost more then the sandwich, I like their fries and fry sauce! Crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. A few of us have actually just ordered the fries before.

Food: 4

Service: 5

Judy White

We went there today at about 2:30
Paid $29.00 and some change got home no cheese no lettuce the other on̈e has about five strings of cheese
VERY disappointed

Food: 1

Will Secunde

Chicken parm was amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alexis Symonds

Great place! First timer and was really impressed. I had the chicken cold sub and my bf had a pastrami cold sub. We both enjoyed our subs and the service was great! We’ll be back :)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Shakti

Go to sub shop for sure. Highly recommend the herbivore, and fries!!

Alex Manfredi

great italian sub, would recommend

James Joel Holmes

Best subs in town! Customer service always friendly.

Eric Johnson

Absolutely horrible sandwich! You know there's a big problem when you put something in your mouth and you can't taste anything that you can identify… I ordered a hot Philly steak sandwich.There was some sort of weird aftertaste that really took over the entire sandwich. Inside the sandwich I see that it is created with paper thin slices of beef, in fact it was more like a beef-mush sandwich than a sliced Philly steak sandwich. I was surprised at how quickly they were able to make it because I was there for less than two minutes When they brought it out.so this meat was obviously Pre-cooked and probablysitting in some sort of juice that totally ruined this. they talk about their incredible sandwiches on their website well if you wanted to make an incredible sandwich you don't do it by pre-cooking your steak for the Philly steak sandwich. Especially for a shop that doesn't have a drive-in window or offer quick service. I definitely do not recommend this place

Home

Bonnie’s my girl! Always gets me the best sandwiches - she makes my day better

CCdude

OK let me start out saying this place is run by a great crew with great service. However the food is a different matter. Stay away from the fries, super greasy The chicken sub didn't have much flavor, but the wife's sub was tasty. If you still want fries ask them to cook them extra crispy.

CoryC1033 (CoryC1033)

Meh. Great cheese steak. Closes at 5pm. So unless you want lunch. You're out of luck. I go to Capriottis because they don't hold banker's hours. Just not going to order sandwiches 2 hours before my family can eat them.

Hunter Sartori

You definitely need to try this place you want an amazing sub then look no further dog burger they've got those too come and check em out

Loading...