Maglio's Pizza & Taproom

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+54 photos
+53 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Great pizza but they almost never read any instructions on delivery orders. Multiple times we’ve asked them to NOT reheat slices because we will be reheating them later. Every single time they reheat them. Meaning when we are ready to eat, we basically are super over cooking them just to warm them up. The receipt *clearly* says “do not heat.”
We love their pizza! Both the regular hand tossed and the gluten free crusts are good. Toppings are a bit pricey, but we usually order cheese pizzas which are a good deal. Every once in a while it’d be nice to have more cheese or the gf needs to be cooked longer. If it’s a big problem, they are responsive about making it right. That’s not something that happens often. Just a couple times after ordering from them at least a dozen times.
I have searched for years for NY pizza ever since I moved from NY and no one has come close except this restaurant. I just moved here and I’ve eaten here 5 times already. Everything they make is delicious and the sauce is perfection. See yall next week and I can’t wait!

More Reviews