We arrived at AJ's and found a sign at the door “Closed - Sorry for the Inconvenience.” Very disappointed.
Andrea Wagner Passarella
First time dining at AJ’s and hopefully not the last.
Food was fresh and delicious. Caesar salad, oysters Rockefeller and scallops piccata were stellar.
Our server, Zack, was friendly and attentive.
One of the best dining experiences.
LINDA
We had to wait a few minutes for our tale so we went to the bar. The bartender -Zach was amazing - great suggestions and even better drinks. Our waitress Katie was very knowledgable and never missed a beat with service. I had the special which was Maui-maui and my husband had shrimp - both meals were very good and more than enough food. It was a bit loud as hard floors and high ceilings but not bad.
De
Great service, friendly staff, food was excellent. Will eat here every time we are in town
Megan
We found this local gem during our trip. It was a pretty spot with good food and drinks. We were happy with our dining experience to celebrate my daughter's 30th birthday.
Brittany Marie
The food and drink were stellar - truly well balanced and delicious. Such reasonable pricing for top tier cooking! I’m surprised someone had a bad experience because I had such a lovely time here. (I think it’s important to note I came here on Pony Penning day.) The waiters were kind and helpful and the food came well within a reasonable time.
Eva Forsythe
Absolutely worst experience!!! Went in to be seated, was told I would have had to wait another 45 mins….asked for manager and got seated but waited at the table for over 20mins to be served….no one showed up, even after asking.
Service: 1
Warren Lebovics
By far the best sit-down restaurant on the island - the calamari, caesar salad, lamb, and vodka sauce pasta pasta are all top notch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
LUC MARRA
great food, great service, a lil bit overpriced!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Billy and Megan Burriss
Went here while on a anniversary getaway with my husband and they have the BEST food on the island! We had the steak filet and it was perfect! The crab cake was also delicious! The staff is very welcoming and friendly. The resturant is cozy and clean. We will be back next year!
I’m not a fan of seafood so I decided to step out of the box and try fresh seafood from the island. The shrimp platter was awesome. The fried flounder the next day was fresh and tasty. They have absolutely the best Orange Crushes on the island! Service was exceptional. Most of my family ordered the crab soup and said it was outstanding! Sara is the absolutely best waitress. I can’t wait to come back to the island to eat here again. Number 1 orange crushes on the island!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Devon Cook
The best orange crush on the island! Plus Sarah is the best server/bartender around. I’ll be dreaming about their oyster rockefeller until the next trip
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Gigantone
Our lunch was delicious!! Sara makes the best orange crushes!! The burger bowl was amazing! The crab soup was outstanding. The soft shell crab sandwich was incredible. Everything we had we wanted to order more!
Deborah Boersma
Exceptional food. The staff could not have been nicer or more efficient. Just a lovely place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristen C
Half of the restaurant was empty. Would not seat us, said we'd have to wait 45 min.
We arrived at AJ's and found a sign at the door “Closed - Sorry for the Inconvenience.” Very disappointed.
First time dining at AJ’s and hopefully not the last. Food was fresh and delicious. Caesar salad, oysters Rockefeller and scallops piccata were stellar. Our server, Zack, was friendly and attentive. One of the best dining experiences.
We had to wait a few minutes for our tale so we went to the bar. The bartender -Zach was amazing - great suggestions and even better drinks. Our waitress Katie was very knowledgable and never missed a beat with service. I had the special which was Maui-maui and my husband had shrimp - both meals were very good and more than enough food. It was a bit loud as hard floors and high ceilings but not bad.
Great service, friendly staff, food was excellent. Will eat here every time we are in town
We found this local gem during our trip. It was a pretty spot with good food and drinks. We were happy with our dining experience to celebrate my daughter's 30th birthday.
The food and drink were stellar - truly well balanced and delicious. Such reasonable pricing for top tier cooking! I’m surprised someone had a bad experience because I had such a lovely time here. (I think it’s important to note I came here on Pony Penning day.) The waiters were kind and helpful and the food came well within a reasonable time.
Absolutely worst experience!!! Went in to be seated, was told I would have had to wait another 45 mins….asked for manager and got seated but waited at the table for over 20mins to be served….no one showed up, even after asking.
Service: 1
By far the best sit-down restaurant on the island - the calamari, caesar salad, lamb, and vodka sauce pasta pasta are all top notch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
great food, great service, a lil bit overpriced!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went here while on a anniversary getaway with my husband and they have the BEST food on the island! We had the steak filet and it was perfect! The crab cake was also delicious! The staff is very welcoming and friendly. The resturant is cozy and clean. We will be back next year!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I’m not a fan of seafood so I decided to step out of the box and try fresh seafood from the island. The shrimp platter was awesome. The fried flounder the next day was fresh and tasty. They have absolutely the best Orange Crushes on the island! Service was exceptional. Most of my family ordered the crab soup and said it was outstanding! Sara is the absolutely best waitress. I can’t wait to come back to the island to eat here again. Number 1 orange crushes on the island!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best orange crush on the island! Plus Sarah is the best server/bartender around. I’ll be dreaming about their oyster rockefeller until the next trip
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Our lunch was delicious!! Sara makes the best orange crushes!! The burger bowl was amazing! The crab soup was outstanding. The soft shell crab sandwich was incredible. Everything we had we wanted to order more!
Exceptional food. The staff could not have been nicer or more efficient. Just a lovely place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Half of the restaurant was empty. Would not seat us, said we'd have to wait 45 min.
Service: 1
Loading...