15 Best Italian Restaurants near Middletown

“I ❤️ Italian Touch's steak and cheese. Their pizza is fantastic, also. We go frequently for the lunch specials. Quick enough service to enjoy the meal and get back to work on time. Iykyk, if you don't know, don't hesitate to try them. You most likely won't be disappointed.“

“Had Easter dinner at Carrabba's/ 0226. Food was delicious and server (Janette C) did an outstanding job. She hustles and is focused on service, glad we were seated in her section.“

“Great Italian food, homemade pastas and wonderful list of red wines! Love Love the Spanish octopus, aioli, crushed potatoes!“

“steak and cheese sub was a top 3 ever for me.“

“I had a salad and a personal meat lover's pizza. From the time I entered the restaurant until I paid my check and left I received excellent and friendly service. The salad was fresh and delicious. The pizza was outstanding, among the very best that I have ever had. I highly recommend this restaurant ro anyone that appreciates good Italian food at reasonable prices and with excellent personal service.“

“The food is excellent, everything on the menu is just wonderful. The music from the ceiling speakers could be turned DOWN a good bit.“

“The dinner we had for takeout was superb and the price was right. After a 10 hour drive it was comforting to enjoy a great dinner. I did not eat in the dining room however the place looked amazing and very clean and well laid out. I would definitely like to experience an in restaurant meal. Next time.“

“We were part of a large party for dinner on a Saturday night. The table we reserved was ready when we arrived. The waitress did a great job keeping up with all the orders and keeping tracking of who was with who for the check.
Lots of food options and reseasonable prices.“

“We went to Castiglia’s around 8pm last night after my son’s baseball game. We had a super sweet waitress. She complimented me on my baseball earrings. I LOVED my special cheese steak sub. It was so good! Hubby & son loved their meals. Thank you! We will be back. 😊 🍽️“

“Was delighted to discover this little haven. Quality surpassed most other local Italian eateries yet prices were very fair! We'll be back!“

“Didn’t expect to find such great pizza when our truck broke down in the middle of who knows where. The kindest waitress and a fantastic pizza.“

“My daughter brought me a cheese steak to my home in Alexandria and I was like OMG this is awesome.....she told me it was a place in Winchester called Claudio's, well I told her that it is worth a trip for me to travel for such an awesome cheese steak and this was a 2 hr old one at that!! I made the trip this past Sunday with my grandson and stopped into Claudio's, the food, cheesesteak's awesome, onion rings were crispy and flavorful, service was kind, friendly and helpful. The manager on duty was awesome, I told him I traveled from Alexandria just to dine at the Pizzeria and he made sure that we enjoyed are visit! Thank you Claudio's and we will be sure to visit again very soon.“

“Quickly delivered an amazing pizza to the Marriott. Would recommend trying if you are in the area.“

“Rica comida italiana a buen precio , porciones , grandes y un buen servicio al cliente …. Quede encantada de este lugar“

“It’s always so nice having a meal at Ledo’s. The staff and owner are always so nice and personable and the food is so good. Pizza, a salad and a diet Dr Pepper for me usually but I can’t wait to try the wings! I’ve heard they’re really good!!“