One Way Cream & Goodies

One Way Cream & Goodies is a fun ice cream shop that offers a customizable ice cream experience. Customers can choose to add breakfast cereal, mix-ins, drizzles, and whipped cream to their treats. The shop also provides vegan ice cream, milkshakes, water ice, and pretzels, bringing back childhood memories of summer. Flavors like banana pudding ice cream are highly praised for their creaminess and delicious taste, making many customers plan to return for more.

The store may appear empty when visitors first arrive because the staff often run the One Way market across the street at the same time. Once someone walks in, they come over to assist. Some customers have mentioned that if no one is at the counter, they might leave without trying the ice cream, which is unfortunate since the milkshakes and ice cream are amazing. Each order is made fresh and fully customized, so there may be a wait if the shop is busy, but it is absolutely worth it. For those who want a customized treat, they can start with vanilla or chocolate ice cream and add cereal, a "goodie" (like a baked good or topping), a drizzle, and whipped cream. The shop also sells ice cream by the scoop and offers signature milkshakes such as Death By Chocolate for those who prefer ready-made options.

Visitors have shared positive experiences, describing the large, tasty portions that are perfect for sharing. Although seating is limited to a few barstools inside and two picnic tables outside, it usually does not pose a problem. The shop has a lively, up-and-coming vibe, with many customers excited about the cereal mix-in concept, which they find unique and satisfying. People who love thick shakes will find this place ideal, as their milkshakes are rich and hold their texture well, even when taken home. The extensive selection for creating custom treats can be a little overwhelming for first timers, but the creativity and quality make One Way Cream & Goodies a popular spot that many customers plan to visit again.