Proper Pie Co.
2505 E Broad St #100, Richmond
(804) 343-7437
Customers' Favorites
KeyLime \u0026 Coconut Meringue
Salted Caramel Pumpkin Pie
Buttermilk Raspberry
Chocolate Pecan Pie
Leek and Potato Pie
Bacon & Gouda Pasty
Banana Cream Pie
Steak and Cheese
Banana Creme Pie
Chocolate Chess
Menu
Photos
+85 photos
+84 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
My husband and I are VCU alumni and drive from northern VA just to eat here. Always fresh, always hot and always buttery flaky perfection. As my husband puts it, “If Patrick Henry were still alive, he’d bust his pantaloons eating this.”
Thank you Proper Pie for making us happy.
Thank you Proper Pie for making us happy.
Recommend to try from a friend. Did NOT disappoint.
Best turtle of anything I've ever had. Great key lime, not too tangy. Lemon blueberry is so warm & cozy. They also have savory options. I don't even choose pie for my desserts but these are outstanding.
Order at the window. No indoor seating but a few spots are available on the sidewalk.
Best turtle of anything I've ever had. Great key lime, not too tangy. Lemon blueberry is so warm & cozy. They also have savory options. I don't even choose pie for my desserts but these are outstanding.
Order at the window. No indoor seating but a few spots are available on the sidewalk.
You May Also Like
The Green Kitchen - located within RVA Food-Co Lab, 9200 Stony Point Pkwy Ste 158-A
![]()
Personal Chefs, Venues & Event Spaces, Caterers
Riverbend Roastery - 2623 E Broad St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Frontier by Alamo - 412 N 25th St
![]()
Barbeque
We ordered the butter chicken (AMAZING!), sausage roll, mince and cheese, steak and cheese, and pork/apple/cheddar for savory pies. Key lime, peach melba, and banofee for sweet pies. Love the crust love everything!