4 Best Italian Restaurants near Staunton

Shenandoah Pizza Pizza • $
19 E Beverley St, Staunton

Customers` Favorites

Shenandoah Special and by
California Chicken Sub
Deep Fried Pickles
Mozzarella Sticks
Pepperoni Pizza
Waffle Fries
Cheese Pizza
Meatball Sub
Chicken Wings
Cheesy Bread

“Big fan of this local spot! Pizza is excellent! Cheesy bread is a fav! Staff is always friendly and attentive. Cool vibes, great ambience! Love when they have local musicians entertaining the crowd! Owner is usually walking around and checking on guests. They regularly support local non-profits! Good people, good place!“

4.1 Good84 Reviews
Stella Mia Pizzeria Pizza • $
2040 W Beverley St #2916, Staunton

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Caesar Salad
Mozzarella Sticks
Stuffed Shells
Bread Sticks
House Salad

“My partner and I stopped in on a Sunday around noon and were greeted and seated quickly. Our server was very nice and knowledgeable of items on the menu and was able to answer all of our questions. She checked in just the right amount of times and brought refills without needing to be asked. We ended up getting an order of bread sticks, stuffed shells, a small stuffed pizza, and a side Caesar salad.Breadsticks:*Crunchy outside, soft inside*Plenty of dipping marinara*Definitely recommendSalad:*The croutons on the ceasar salad are made from the breadstick bread and are so good. I don't normally like croutons because they're usually ridiculously hard, but I ate every single one of these!!*The dressing was different from most other ceasar dressings but still tasted good. It was a little sweet and less tangy.Stuffed pizza:*Very much like a calzone, overall, it was good. You are able to customize the ingredients. There is no sauce inside.Stuffed shells:*2 to a plate. That seemed like it was not going to be enough food, but they were surprisingly filling with lots of cheese.*I enjoyed the marinara, and the pasta was cooked well.*They are about $11, so take that into consideration when you order.Other random thoughts:*Plenty of seating*Plenty of parking*Bathroom was clean*My partner stated that he would have liked the bread items to be slightly *less* cooked/crunchy and it seemed like the oven may be too hot or it was left in a bit too long? I had no issue. These are just our personal preferences, obviously, so take everything with a grain of salt :)Overall, I'm pleased with our meal and the service received. If we are ever in the area again, I would be happy to stop in and try some other dishes and maybe even a dessert!“

4 Good42 Reviews
Maria's Pizza & Italian Restaurant Italian • $
901 Greenville Ave, Staunton

Customers` Favorites

Two Suces Cheese Pizza
Create Yamr Own Pasta
Dinner Salad Included
Chicken Parmigiana
Garlic Knots
Caesar Salad
Bruschetta
Italian
Slice

“I never bother to leave reviews, if I like the place I like it, I’d I don’t I don’t. The bite(s) I had of my girlfriend’s penne alla vodka was immaculate; quite possibly the best I’ve ever had. My pizza steak wasn’t as packed with meats as I would’ve preferred but the flavor was simply incredible.“

3.8 Good57 Reviews
Brother's Pizza & Italian Restaurant Pizza • $
74 Orchard Hill Cir #110, Staunton

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Steak Sub
Meatlovers Pizza
Fried Mushrooms
Supreme Pizza
Garlic Bread
Cheese Pizza
Meat Pizza
Stromboli
Hamburger
Italian

“Food-The sub was the bomb! No gristle, gristly (did I spell that right?) pieces!! I asked for the cheese steak hoagie without the cheese, add lettuce, tomato and light mayo. That was delicious!!Service- the lady that answered the phone was awesome! Kind & courtesy!Atmosphere- needs a major overhaul! Meaning it was decorated by the original owner in 199something....“

3.7 Good60 Reviews
Loading...
map Map