Sal's NY Pie Pizzeria
$ • Pizza, Salad, Italian
Hours:
4640 Shore Dr STE 102, Virginia Beach
(757) 937-6917
About Sal's NY Pie Pizzeria
Customers' Favorites
Sal's NY Pie Pizzeria Reviews
Share your opinion about Sal's NY Pie Pizzeria
Date of Experience: March 14, 2025
Order Details: Delivery placed online at 6:45 PM
Experience:
My wife and I, originally from New York and familiar with quality pizza, chose to celebrate a special occasion by ordering from what used to be our favorite pizzeria. Despite the higher prices, we've always valued their quality.
After placing our order at 6:45 PM, we received a notification at 7:15 PM stating the delivery was on its way. By 7:45...read full review
I bought 1 slice today with sausage. It was gross. reheated and they put a few sprinkles of mozzarella on it. I threw it out after 1 bite. Nothing like NY pizza. I have had better frozen than this
Beware of this business. I placed a delivery order that was never delivered (for whatever reason). I spoke to the owner and instead of making it right, he insisted it was delivered and was quite hostile in his refusal to refund my payment to the point I was hung up on. On principal alone, I have filed a dispute with my credit card company. I will never order from here again and I don't recommend anyone else does. No sense rewarding unscrupulous sorts with our business.
Menu
Hours
| Monday | 10:15AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 10:15AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 10:15AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 10:30AM - 10PM |
| Saturday | 10:30AM - 10PM |
| Sunday | 10:15AM - 9PM |
People in Virginia Beach Also Viewed
Sal's NY Pie Pizzeria is a popular spot serving delicious pizza, calzone, steak rolls, and stromboli that are a little slice of NY right on Shore Drive. The staff is efficient and courteous, and they offer party platters for special occasions like Super Bowl Sunday. The Gyros are ready quickly and reasonably priced. Customers say the pizza is truly a New York style, with many claiming it’s the real deal and much better than low-quality franchise options. The restaurant has plenty of close parking and is wheelchair accessible. Customers also enjoy the friendly delivery service and the variety of Italian dishes, including pineapple and ham pie and lasagna. Many appreciate that the food always comes faster than expected, and the delivery drivers are friendly. The place also offers a 24" pie perfect for feeding a crowd. Overall, it’s a spot with reasonable prices, tasty food, and an authentic NY style pizza experience that keeps customers coming back weekly. The atmosphere is low key and welcoming, with a family story that adds a personal touch to the authentic experience.