Shields Tavern
422 E Duke of Gloucester St, Williamsburg
(855) 268-7220
Customers' Favorites
Mashed Potatoes Fried Chicken Beef Roll
Warm Wild Berry Crumble
Braised Beef Short Rib
Fried Chicken Breast
Fried Chicken Dinner
Apple Green Salad
Chopped Salad
Roast Chicken
Chocolate Cake
Squash Soup
Menu
Photos
+67 photos
+66 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
It was fun and parts of the meal were excellent. The salad, beef pie, mashed potatoes and dessert were very nicely done. The chicken was dry and very salty. We went for the Christmas groaning board and finished just before the Grand Illumination which is right outside the door. Expensive but it's a great overall experience.
This Tavern, along with the staff, and a waitress who had not only great server skills, but a wonderful side of great attitude to go along with it!!! I was there with my son on Thursday, 10/9/25 and will prayerfully return ASAP!!! The music/singing transported me back to a more genteel era, and as I am a true fan of the years '1732 - 1834;' it was indeed a breath of fresh air!! God bless you all for all you did/do!! Best endeavors, Letitia Cline
We visited last week with a school group for a colonial dining experience. The fried chicken, potato pudding, vegetables, and biscuit were delicious. The lemonade was also refreshing. However, many of us were quite disappointed with the yellow cake with white frosting and sprinkles that was served for dessert. It did not seem like an authentic colonial dessert, but rather like a grocery store sheet cake. In addition the gluten free guests received a beautiful and delicious Strawberry...
You May Also Like
King's Arms Tavern - 416 E Duke of Gloucester St
![]()
Southern, American, Bar, Vegetarian
Raleigh Tavern Bakery - 410 E Duke of Gloucester St
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Bakery
Dubois Grocer - 305 E Duke of Gloucester St
![]()
Candy Store, Bakery, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt