Rusty's Pizza & Pie

48 Old Rte 15, Cambridge
(802) 644-2011

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Grant Hall

Great people, great pizza! So good had to write a review while eating it.

Logan Pollard

Called and asked for a piece of grilled chicken…. they said no? So you can do a kids chicken tender but can’t put a piece of chicken on the grill and charge the same for it? Kid who answered the phone asked another person and he got mad about me asking for a piece of grilled chicken lol. joke of a place.

craig holcomb

Good food and the prices are reasonable.

Boss Roy

Went here for the very first time, and the pizza was very good. I highly recommend. Can’t wait to try more of their menu.

Stellar Wicker

Our pizza was delicious and the space was chill- our server was kind, all around good place!!

Kyle Leighton

This place is a gem! It’s a small spot that mainly does takeout, but the inside is clean, bright, and welcoming with comfortable bar seating, a cozy corner table, and quirky decor that gives it tons of character. They even have mini arcade games for diners to play while they wait—super thoughtful and fun, especially for kids!

The guys working there were incredibly personable and attentive—just genuinely great service. We ordered a small cheese pizza, a white pizza, the maple ginger salad, a slice of buffalo chicken pizza, a meatball calzone, and a salted chocolate chip cookie. Every single thing was fantastic. The dough is light, crispy, and full of flavor, and the maple ginger dressing was out of this world. Not a single bite was lacking in flavor.

They’ll be serving ice cream soon too, and they generously let us sample some—it was amazing. We can’t wait to go back!

Dan Crowley

Solid pizza, friendly people

Emily Koch

Amazing pizzas and salads! Ordered to go and everything came out great. Pizzas were delicious and had a great crust thickness. Salads blew our expectations out of the water! The Maple Ginger salad was excellent, tons of the good toppings and very tasty dressing. High quality greens and veggies in the salads and on pizzas. Outstanding takeout for anyone staying near Smuggler’s Notch!

Keith Lynch

Fantastic cheesy Garlic bread and Buffalo chicken pizza is perfect!!!

reese singer

Best pizza in the area, hands down! The desserts are to die for. Small dining room and parking can be difficult but the food is worth it!

Joe Hannon

These folks took over the footprint to a local legend and they're doing it right. The classic pies are exceptional, the modern pies are exceptional, the staff is great.

M R

Intimate atmosphere. Fast service. Food delicious - highly recommend the buffalo chicken pizza!

Eric Beverage

Ordered for pickup and I gotta say, I absolutely loved my pizza 🍕

Daniella Alise

👍👍 superb

Mike David

Stopped in for an impromptu date night! Found ourselves kidless for a few hours, and sure are glad we stopped in! Meatball sub, French fries, a calzone, and a seat at the bar! Great vibe, nice people. Awesome food. Highly recommend.

Loading...