36 Best Pizza Restaurants near Colchester

“I ordered two pizzas today. One pepperoni and one cheese. Both were cooked well and the pizza used quality ingredients and had no oil or grease drip. The undercarriage was perfect and had a nice crisp to it. Color was spot on and slices are huge. Will buy again!“

“Loyal Zachs customers here, an easy go-to! ❤️“

“New York Pizza Oven was a great choice while visiting Colchester/Burlington for the 2022 UVM graduation!“

“New place, looks great, and food is awesome!!“

“Street parking, small and cozy restaurant and reservation recommended.
Our first time there and not impressed with the food. Service was very good, cocktail was rather small for the $17 charged and had a very strong cardamom taste. Pizza was ok. Crust was a little on the soft side (partly soggy). Looks like the Verace style but far from having the same taste and texture.“

“Matt and I have been to Hoagies in Essex a few times as of late and have had the best experience. The servers are amazing, the quality of food is consistent and tasty and we always feel welcome. If you’re wanting quick, yummy eats look no further. Treat yourself to the house Italian dressing. It’s been my favorite since I was a little kid in the 90’s!“

“Recommend this establishment any day“

“Absolutely delicious!!! From appetizer selection to entre. Every special occasion and family group eat outs here from now on.“

“With the country going the way it has been. It’s places like this that raise my spirits. Community is what matters. This is a place that believes that. Oh and it has great food and service. Keep standing by your beliefs and I believe our community will keep standing by you.“

“Great pizza and friendly staff. The outdoor dinning is perfect. I think number one pizza in all of Vermont. 😊“

“The food, wine, latte, and cannoli were fabulous! Lexi provided exceptional service — her menu suggestions and insights were spot on. We’ll definitely be back!“

“I recently had my third visit to Stone's Throw Pizza in Fairfax, and it was another fantastic experience. This time, I tried the 16" Blues in the Night pizza, and it was absolutely delicious. The white sauce base, combined with the herbed ricotta, created a rich and creamy foundation, while the blueberries and fresh basil added a unique and refreshing twist. The honey drizzle brought everything together perfectly, balancing out the flavors with just the right amount of sweetness.

The Caesar Salad was fresh and crisp, with the romaine lettuce providing a nice crunch. The asiago cheese added a sharp, tangy flavor that complemented the house-made croutons and Caesar dressing. I appreciated that the dressing was served on the side, allowing me to control the amount and keep the salad from becoming soggy. Paired with a refreshing ginger ale, it made for a satisfying meal.

The service was prompt and friendly, with the staff attentive to every detail. The ambiance at Stone's Throw Pizza is warm and inviting, making it a great spot to relax and enjoy a meal. The rustic décor and cozy atmosphere create a perfect setting for a casual dining experience. Whether you're a local or just passing through Fairfax, this place is definitely worth a visit!“

“The flatbread pizza and the capicola sandwich was a flavor and texture experience you're going to have to try for yourself to understand. Fresh ingredients, attention to details, lots of flavor and love which was relished with every bite! If you are looking for high quality delicatessan meats, fresh homemade crispy breads and creamy burrata you are going to love it here! Sadly, I forgot to take a photo of the most amazing Tiramisu, which was out of this world delicious! Also where else in Burlington can you enjoy your meal on an incredibly comfortable couch?“

“This was last week: My family decided to get some pizza at Folino’s after going to City Market. Because after getting some healthy things, we were down for some bad decisions. Folino’s Pizza next to a dispensary which honestly was probably their best move possible. The place was PACKED like sardines. (Which I had on pizza once and never again…. Why don’t we ever argue this? Why do people actually argue to the death about pineapple on pizza and NOT HAIRY FISH??? Why are we so divided on this?!) The menu was pretty interesting and easy to follow and we picked two pizzas and wings…. We sat down…. After we paid….. after we tipped, before service was done. I would soon be able to conclude why. You can literally pick a seat anywhere and get a nice glass of water from cups that had seen better days and worse mouths. Next to the garbages…. Next to where you pick your silverware…. My son helped her restock the water. Totally fine. And then we saw…. The utensil/sauce station. Well…. It was PACKED. Garlic, parmesan, salt, pepper, hot sauce, pepper flakes. Some empty, others at various stages of full and honestly take your pick. We got one of each. Went through silverware and it was like a treasure hunt! Some had old food and stains on them and I got to see what popular picks were at this place:-) I think we made the right picks!!! While I like leftovers at home, these were not the leftovers I had a hankering for… decided to pick else wear and found some that were clean clean. Again this place is packed! Line going out the door( to be fair there may have been a few who got mixed up with the Jazz Lettuce place next door). The food sounded/smelled so delicious. We were already hungry and down for some wildfire awesomeness…. And now, we wait….. and wait…. And wait some more. Did…. Did they forget about us? I see some people eating, some people who look famished and well we decided to shoot our shot and ask people how long they had been waiting/if they ordered. Yes. Just yes. The line is moving and fast. I went to their website to see if it was like Disney with the fast passes or something… I can’t even begin to tell you how bummed I am writing that “no” here. After like an hour the wings came out. And I swear to God, with seasoning wings, these kids understood the assignment. However taking a bit of the wing, the chicken fought back. The chicken skin was….. oh God, a good vet could have saved it... a while later, the Buff Chick came out and oh sweet mother of God those candied jalapeños are just the bees knees…then they bought out The Vegan Supreme…. No onions…. And she made a point to say, no onions…. So I knew immediately, there was onions somewhere… which is just fine. My mouth just tingles and gets kinda itchy. Aside from that lil fun fact about me….. those pizzas were amazing and the crust is just what you’d want. And despite a crowded kitchen with no hair nets and loose styles everywhere, there was little to no hair in the food! The pizza is definitely worth buying just not the wait unless you have the afternoon and no perishable groceries in your car (City Market) to waste…. My guess with the line out the door, they preordered online within a couple hours getting there. My husband loved that we tipped to have the home experience and got to not only wait on ourselves and clean up after our selves, he also loved that he was able to clean the table off from the previous people and the bundle of pizza tray holders from them as well. My son loved that he found a wing order he didn’t want to touch at all. If you have an afternoon to waste by the water cooler and tables with an awesome pizza sheen on it… get here faster then they open. You won’t be disappointed with disappointment. Buttttt, (and this is a big but here) if you want some awesome pizza with awesome flavor and amazing crust, definitely get it here. Just order online. Get all your chores and shopping done… maybe make time for a movie. After all that, it might be ready and you too can be in the line out the door…. Looking at all the people in the dining area like you dodg“

“I stopped in and had a small Zack special pizza. The food was good. The building was a little echoy. Looks like they were going some remodeling . I would go again.“

“I had their pizza and garlic knots and the oh-so-tasty marinara a few years ago and I absolutely hope to visit again someday! would love like a gallon of that marinara!! so good!“

“Fresh, tasty, and authentic! Thanks Carlo and the crew for a great lunch and dinner. We had a fresh salad and tasty garlic bites in their awesome restaurant, then took home 2 great pizzas for dinner later that evening. All our ingredients were fresh, and well seasoned, ricotta to die for! We got a mickster and a prosciutto pie and, can’t wait to go back and try more!“

“I am from New Jersey.I remember they had a spot in Woodbridge mall and until recently I believed them to be the alternate to sbarro shopping mall pizza.I was wrongBack home, we had dozens of top notch pizzerias so I never tried them but up here in vermont I can honestly tell youThey make good pie.Easily one of the best New York style pies around.Take that to the bank.“

“My friend and I went for dinner… we started with the poutine, and it was excellent! My friend had the pepperoni pizza and I had the bacon avocado burger with onion rings. Both entrées were amazing! Also, we really enjoyed the margaritas. They were very fresh tasting! Everything we had was fresh and delicious. I would definitely recommend and we will definitely be going back again!“

“You can technically get better pizza, but it's pretty good overall. I represent a club on the university campus and specifically wanted to call out their delivery driver David Shapiro; an absolute professional. When he called me to let us know he was here with our order, he knew off the bat exactly where on campus to go; we found him first try. They should send him on all orders that go to the UVM campus.“

“Pizza is good, prices are nice compared to other places around. Someone said it is like the domino's of Burlington. That makes sense to me. I only tried cheese pizza and breadsticks. I like the marina dipping sauce they use. We got take-out so I can't rate much else. It serves for a good late night snack too. ?“

“We just had a great visit here personally! We had some slices in and then ordered a white pie to go. Place was busy with take out and as resident NYC gal I can see why. Will be back every Sat! Had my son with autism order for us to practice and the staff member working register was so cool about it. We appreciate that giys!“

“This has to be the best domino's in vt don't understand the low rating you have. Only problem i have is domino's website. Not this locations fault. Domino's corporate needs to took some of billions of dollars they make and pay better it people.....“

“i am so glad to be able to write a new, improved review!!!! first time ever trying this place a month ago was a complete disaster😞😞😞 didn’t think i’d ever return. however everyone deserves a second chance!!! was pleasantly surprised to feel like there’s been a major improvement so i highly encourage others who may have been disappointed to give them another chance. service was 100 % better, food was great and done right as well. happy customers😉😁❤️“

“I love Burlington dominoes because they know how they do it the one on the left is Burlington Domino’s chicken the one on the right is Plattsburgh’s chicken I ordered you tell me how you want your meal messed up or neatly!“

“On a road trip from out of state, googled some options and was recommended Jrs from another restaurant that was reservations only tonight; so very happy that’s how it worked out! We called ahead to make sure they had openings and the girl I talked to was very friendly. Upon arrival though they mentioned they don’t take reservations they had a table for 5 ready for us. Coming from out of state with 3 kids of different ages there were a lot of questions about the menu and our waitress Lexi was patient and kind; speaking with them directly and making sure to answer all questions. Drinks were refilled without asking, extra napkins supplied, she kept an eye out and checked in regularly. The food was fantastic as well, but Lexi was superb!“

“After recently moving back to Vermont, I order from this specific Domino’s Pizza as it used to be my go to. Come to find a nice surprise to see Justin back at this location again. I used to go to this specific Dominos just because of Justin’s customer service. He always greets customers with a big smile and is always courteous. It’s rare to find someone who takes such pride in their work and goes the extra mile to make sure customers are satisfied. Thank you Justin!“

“I eat Domino's pizza pretty regularly. For the past couple years I've come to accept that my order was going to miss the mark in preparation and/or presentation-- undercooked or burned, skimpy cheese (including the time I ordered extra cheese), skimpy toppings, or slices flipped upside down in the box, all of which impacts my perception of taste and overall enjoyment. I hesitated to order today, but wanted to try the North Ave location since I haven't been there before. The pizza I got at North Ave was perfect! Opened the lid and wow that thing looked so goooood in the box, like sunlight was pouring out of it :-D Cut perfectly too, I couldn't wait to get home and tear into it. I told the young man who made it how pleased and grateful I was. Wish I'd had more than a couple dollars for the tip jar. I hope he's on the job next time I order cuz he reminded me of why I enjoy Dominos.“

“Best Italian in Colchester area“

“I ordered 2 medium pepperoni pizzas. I’ve NEVER got a basic pepperoni pizza with this much pepperoni! It was a beautiful thing to see not one BUT two pizzas cooked to perfection with a decent amount of its topping! I always get fast delivery as well and the one time it was expected to be late I received a call stating there was a possibility of a late delivery-it arrived on time. 😊 5 Stars to the Essex Location.“

“Fun place great pizza! Great location“

“Amazing and friendly and delivery service“

“Amazing place, great food.“

“Growing up in NY, I’ve missed “real” pizza for the 50 yrs I’ve been in BTV. You guys have filled the gap and surpassed anything in this area. Amazing pizza. Thanks so much.“