Italian Restaurants near Colchester

“I ordered two pizzas today. One pepperoni and one cheese. Both were cooked well and the pizza used quality ingredients and had no oil or grease drip. The undercarriage was perfect and had a nice crisp to it. Color was spot on and slices are huge. Will buy again!“

“New York Pizza Oven was a great choice while visiting Colchester/Burlington for the 2022 UVM graduation!“

“The food, wine, latte, and cannoli were fabulous! Lexi provided exceptional service — her menu suggestions and insights were spot on. We’ll definitely be back!“

“Excellent Italian food! Staff is very friendly“

“The wait staff were really on top of it when I went. Pretty much as soon as we scarfed down the last breadstick they had brought us another plate of them. They're good bread sticks too. Same as with drinks, I never went more than a whole minute without a drink refill

I got just a basic spaghetti Alfredo and my sister got a spaghetti with the 5 cheese marinara and meatballs. While mine was really good, hers was great.

Prices weren't terrible either“

“On a road trip from out of state, googled some options and was recommended Jrs from another restaurant that was reservations only tonight; so very happy that’s how it worked out! We called ahead to make sure they had openings and the girl I talked to was very friendly. Upon arrival though they mentioned they don’t take reservations they had a table for 5 ready for us. Coming from out of state with 3 kids of different ages there were a lot of questions about the menu and our waitress Lexi was patient and kind; speaking with them directly and making sure to answer all questions. Drinks were refilled without asking, extra napkins supplied, she kept an eye out and checked in regularly. The food was fantastic as well, but Lexi was superb!“

“Best Italian in Colchester area“

“Something about the meatballs in the spaghetti made me not eat them... couldnt tell you why but the wine selection is incredible!!! Please also get a desert, any dessert and also a seasonal appetizer if you would be so inclined. Very vibes tiny teeny dining space, I love it.“

“Matt and I have been to Hoagies in Essex a few times as of late and have had the best experience. The servers are amazing, the quality of food is consistent and tasty and we always feel welcome. If you’re wanting quick, yummy eats look no further. Treat yourself to the house Italian dressing. It’s been my favorite since I was a little kid in the 90’s!“

“Absolutely delicious!!! From appetizer selection to entre. Every special occasion and family group eat outs here from now on.“

“I stopped in and had a small Zack special pizza. The food was good. The building was a little echoy. Looks like they were going some remodeling . I would go again.“

“Great pizza and friendly staff. The outdoor dinning is perfect. I think number one pizza in all of Vermont. 😊“

“I had their pizza and garlic knots and the oh-so-tasty marinara a few years ago and I absolutely hope to visit again someday! would love like a gallon of that marinara!! so good!“

“Pizza is good, prices are nice compared to other places around. Someone said it is like the domino's of Burlington. That makes sense to me. I only tried cheese pizza and breadsticks. I like the marina dipping sauce they use. We got take-out so I can't rate much else. It serves for a good late night snack too. ?“

“Fun place great pizza! Great location“

“Amazing place, great food.“