Fair Haven Pizza House & Subs
$ • Pizza, ItalianAbout Fair Haven Pizza House & Subs
Customers' Favorites
Recent Reviews
Share your opinion about Fair Haven Pizza House & Subs
The owners are the best people and still have the best food around after all the years.
Lucy and her whole family are such hard workers who make the best Pizza and Subs ever!!!
The photos of everyone on the wall really brings you back 30 + years now! Wow such a wonderful idea and shows how many people love this place and those who have made it a Staple in Vermont ❤
From Rutland Days to Fair Haven.
We were so Lucky to be able to enjoy this great food...read full review
Fair Haven Pizza House & Subs blew us away. The customer service was phenomenal—our waitress was on top of everything, super friendly, and checked in often to make sure we were all set. She was so helpful that when she asked how things were, all we could say was, “Excellent,” because it truly was.
The food? Out of this world. The pizza was hot, fresh, and packed with flavor, and the wings were exactly what we ordered— juicy, and seriously delicious. Everything came...read full review
Old world style pizza place. Lucy is wonderful, staff is very nice and friendly.
Great pizza and hands down the best Mozzarella sticks on the planet!
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Thursday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Friday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 11AM - 8PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Fair Haven Pizza House & Subs offers delicious homemade pizza, pasta, and grinders with one-of-a-kind rolls made in-house. The owners are kind, and the food is reasonably priced, with many customers making long drives to enjoy the authentic Italian-style dishes. The restaurant maintains its quality and charm in the small town setting, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere that reflects its long-standing history. The owner takes pride in her work, and her personal touches, like a Hall of Fame wall filled with customer pictures and memories from over four decades, add to the special feeling of the place. Customers often praise the friendly staff, quick service, and the flavorful, fresh food, including the garlic bread and pizza, which are considered some of the best around. Overall, it’s a place that combines delicious food, genuine hospitality, and a rich tradition that keeps drawing people back.