Best pizza near Jay Peak, definitely worth driving over to Montgomery for it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Augusta Pendergast
Don catered our wedding, and his pizza was such a hit. It is so incredibly tasty, crispy, and well cooked. There are a great mix of classic and unique flavors, and everyone was blown away by the food. We didn’t have to worry about any elements of the dinner at our wedding. Don came with his own set-up complete with tables, a tent, and plates and cutlery and was ready to go serving pies right at dinner time. I seriously cannot recommend this pizza enough, and would highly recommend hiring Fire on the Mountain for your next event. It’s high quality, genuinely good pizza that everyone can enjoy and brings such a warm, upbeat, and casual mood to any affair. Don is so laid back and we felt so confident going into the wedding that he had everything under control and we had nothing to worry about.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brett Lucas
Highly recommend. We are up for the weekend to ski at Jay and ordered 4 pizzas from FOMP. I took the ride to pick up the pizzas and they are conveniently located, an easy 13 minutes from Jay. Hung out on the porch for a few minutes chatting with the owner who makes the dough from scratch and was pulling my pizzas out of the oven. Delicious. Will be back.
John Bolog
Absolutely the best pie I've had in a long, long time.Delicious!
John Smith
Fast, friendly, tasty.
Andy Bennett
Really good pizza and superfast. Very friendly staff. The pizza seemed one size fits all at about 12-14". All handmade.
Michael Malenfant
As a die hard skier of nearly half a century, I've been in my fair share of ski towns. Much like the search for first tracks through fresh powder, locating good pizza after a day on the slopes is elusive at best and impossible at worst. Fire on the Mountain Pizza solves that riddle: pizza described as "the best pizza ever" by a picky 10 year old and by my healthy eating wife as "a perfect combination of taste that doesn't leave you feeling gross", these pies are legit "can't stop". Not too thin, not to thick crust, a goldilocks perfect ratio of cheese and sauce, and fresh toppings. Great pizza a short drive from the resort and served by someone who cares. Call ahead from the last chair to schedule your pickup and enjoy a perfect pizza to close the day. Props to the Edward Abbey reference in the name. In Abbey's words, "we need the possibly of escape just as surely as we need hope" and this pizza provides both. Be kind, be safe, eat local.
Justin Green
Whenever we can we get our hands on this pizza (which often sells out it’s so good) we do. Whenever our family visits they look forward to and actually require that we have a pizza night from Fire on Mountain. Far and away this is an expertly made pie with the best of the best ingredients. They clearly have a passion for their craft and have developed an amazing technique - to have truly wood fired pizza on the road from wherever they bring their remarkable oven. The veggie, Vermonter, and Hawaiian are among our favorites. Yet every pizza we have had has been nothing but exceptional. It’s sad to see even one negative review but I realize it’s probably from a naysayer that isn’t happy with anything ever. This business is exceptional and deserves praise and support. I am drooling just thinking about it as we speak. Thank you Fire on (the) Mountain!
Elizabeth G
For pizza cooked on a stone, it wasn't as crispy as expected.I ordered pineapple, not Hawaiian, and somehow got Blue Hawaiian (red sauce, pineapple, ham, onions, and BBQ sauce.) This was a huge downer. I don't like ham.I liked the fresh pineapple but wish it had more.
We ordered four pizzas for four people, thinking they were almost personal size. We were pleasantly surprised by the size (somewhere between a normal and personal) and had plenty of leftovers. The pepperoni pizza was fine. The veggie pizza was excellent, cooked just right. The BBQ pork pizza was disappointing- the BBQ sauce was very sweet and the pork didn't have much flavor. The margherita pizza would have been good but was very burnt. Burnt to the point where they should have put another pie in instead of giving it to us.
Ross Novak
It’s so amazing. Must try!!! Super friendly peeps too.
Diana Mata
Best pizza in Montgomery VT. Whether you’re in town for one day, week, month, or longer than that, I highly suggest you save their number and make a stop to Fire on Mountain Pizza a priority. You won’t be disappointed.Personally, I have been here for a week and I look forward to getting a few pizzas every time they’re open. I’ve tried all of them and they’re absolutely delicious. Service is timely and always a pleasant experience. 6 star rating if I could!!
Diana M.
I consider myself a pizza snob. I am always hesitant to try new pizza places because when you have high expectations and a mediocre experience, you're left disappointed and still craving what you envisioned. Fire on the mountain pizza, is absolutely DELICIOUS!! I have ordered pizza every day they're open since the moment I arrived to Montgomery VT. Sometimes I get too excited and order more than I can eat. If I could give this place an extra star, I would.
Shannon R.
The pizza was really yummy but soooo small. It's basically a personal pie, but the flavor was great!
Absolutely delicious Pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza near Jay Peak, definitely worth driving over to Montgomery for it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Don catered our wedding, and his pizza was such a hit. It is so incredibly tasty, crispy, and well cooked. There are a great mix of classic and unique flavors, and everyone was blown away by the food. We didn’t have to worry about any elements of the dinner at our wedding. Don came with his own set-up complete with tables, a tent, and plates and cutlery and was ready to go serving pies right at dinner time. I seriously cannot recommend this pizza enough, and would highly recommend hiring Fire on the Mountain for your next event. It’s high quality, genuinely good pizza that everyone can enjoy and brings such a warm, upbeat, and casual mood to any affair. Don is so laid back and we felt so confident going into the wedding that he had everything under control and we had nothing to worry about.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Highly recommend. We are up for the weekend to ski at Jay and ordered 4 pizzas from FOMP. I took the ride to pick up the pizzas and they are conveniently located, an easy 13 minutes from Jay. Hung out on the porch for a few minutes chatting with the owner who makes the dough from scratch and was pulling my pizzas out of the oven. Delicious. Will be back.
Absolutely the best pie I've had in a long, long time.Delicious!
Fast, friendly, tasty.
Really good pizza and superfast. Very friendly staff. The pizza seemed one size fits all at about 12-14". All handmade.
As a die hard skier of nearly half a century, I've been in my fair share of ski towns. Much like the search for first tracks through fresh powder, locating good pizza after a day on the slopes is elusive at best and impossible at worst. Fire on the Mountain Pizza solves that riddle: pizza described as "the best pizza ever" by a picky 10 year old and by my healthy eating wife as "a perfect combination of taste that doesn't leave you feeling gross", these pies are legit "can't stop". Not too thin, not to thick crust, a goldilocks perfect ratio of cheese and sauce, and fresh toppings. Great pizza a short drive from the resort and served by someone who cares. Call ahead from the last chair to schedule your pickup and enjoy a perfect pizza to close the day. Props to the Edward Abbey reference in the name. In Abbey's words, "we need the possibly of escape just as surely as we need hope" and this pizza provides both. Be kind, be safe, eat local.
Whenever we can we get our hands on this pizza (which often sells out it’s so good) we do. Whenever our family visits they look forward to and actually require that we have a pizza night from Fire on Mountain. Far and away this is an expertly made pie with the best of the best ingredients. They clearly have a passion for their craft and have developed an amazing technique - to have truly wood fired pizza on the road from wherever they bring their remarkable oven. The veggie, Vermonter, and Hawaiian are among our favorites. Yet every pizza we have had has been nothing but exceptional. It’s sad to see even one negative review but I realize it’s probably from a naysayer that isn’t happy with anything ever. This business is exceptional and deserves praise and support. I am drooling just thinking about it as we speak. Thank you Fire on (the) Mountain!
For pizza cooked on a stone, it wasn't as crispy as expected.I ordered pineapple, not Hawaiian, and somehow got Blue Hawaiian (red sauce, pineapple, ham, onions, and BBQ sauce.) This was a huge downer. I don't like ham.I liked the fresh pineapple but wish it had more.
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered four pizzas for four people, thinking they were almost personal size. We were pleasantly surprised by the size (somewhere between a normal and personal) and had plenty of leftovers. The pepperoni pizza was fine. The veggie pizza was excellent, cooked just right. The BBQ pork pizza was disappointing- the BBQ sauce was very sweet and the pork didn't have much flavor. The margherita pizza would have been good but was very burnt. Burnt to the point where they should have put another pie in instead of giving it to us.
It’s so amazing. Must try!!! Super friendly peeps too.
Best pizza in Montgomery VT. Whether you’re in town for one day, week, month, or longer than that, I highly suggest you save their number and make a stop to Fire on Mountain Pizza a priority. You won’t be disappointed.Personally, I have been here for a week and I look forward to getting a few pizzas every time they’re open. I’ve tried all of them and they’re absolutely delicious. Service is timely and always a pleasant experience. 6 star rating if I could!!
I consider myself a pizza snob. I am always hesitant to try new pizza places because when you have high expectations and a mediocre experience, you're left disappointed and still craving what you envisioned. Fire on the mountain pizza, is absolutely DELICIOUS!! I have ordered pizza every day they're open since the moment I arrived to Montgomery VT. Sometimes I get too excited and order more than I can eat. If I could give this place an extra star, I would.
The pizza was really yummy but soooo small. It's basically a personal pie, but the flavor was great!