14 Best Pizza Restaurants near Shrewsbury

“The Rustic Rooster is one of those rare Vermont gems you almost don’t want to share because it’s that special. The food is absolutely amazing — consistently fresh, hearty, and full of flavor. But what really sets this place apart are the people. Greg and Donna, the owners, make you feel like family the moment you walk in. Their team is just as wonderful, and I have to give a special shout-out to Tyler (aka Leroy), whose warmth, humor, and service always make the experience even better. If you’re looking for authentic food, authentic people, and a genuinely welcoming atmosphere, this is it. The Rustic Rooster is easily one of my top spots in Vermont — a true local secret that’s worth discovering.“

“Great Pizza and Service!!“

“They had some of the best Sicilian pizza I've had here, with a nice thick and chewy crust. If you like garlic, get the knots as well--they are doused in minced garlic. Absolutely a delicious meal, and very reasonably priced. It's a great place for a quick lunch, with a few tables inside for seating.“

“Olympic Pizza (and much more) has moved into their new location, now with beer, wine and full bar. Tried it out last night and it was fantastic on every level. Place is squeaky clean and bright/fresh. Brand spanking new. U shaped bar so it's fun to see others and socialize if you're in the mood. They also have numerous tables. A few tvs on the wall for the sports fans. The bartender, Collin, was friendly and personable and took great care of us. The menu is quite diverse with of course pizza, offered in various sizes from personal to BIG! I had the ziti with vodka sauce and you can tell from first bite it's homemade, excellent. My buddies both had pizza and raved. Wine was very good and so reasonably priced!! Good wine at a great price. Such a welcome addition to Rutland, will be going back as there were about 5 other things on the menu I wanted to try. YUM!!!“

“Great Beers Awesome Food Staff friendly & helpful“

“I traveled 1,300 miles and ate here. The staff and food were beyond top notch. One of them little slices of heaven that everyone should enjoy“

“Always greeted at the with a friendly welcome, my order is always correct, and fast service

Parking: Depends how busy they are but most of the time there is plenty of parking. People tend to fly through the parking lot to avoid traffic light or make a quick turnaround so you need to be cautious when backing out.“

“We ate here a few weeks ago, my wife and I were doing some shopping in Rutland and decided to pop by, as we saw their new menu and pictures on FB.

I think their completion is leaving negative reviews so I decided to share. I’ve seen this type of behavior recently going on and it’s unacceptable.

The food was really good and the portions were excellent. The service was spot on. We will be returning with our whole family. Atmosphere is what you would expect for a small town pizza joint. But even that has been improved.

P.S. I tried Ted’s five years ago on my own and another time at my clients home on a sales call, was not impressed. For me, I decided to give them another chance after learning of the new owner and seeing fresh photos. I was pleasantly surprised, new ownership has stepped Ted’s up significantly! 😊“

“Cara Mia's for the win! Got a pizza delivered and there was an incident that involved my 3 yr old slamming the door on the pizza guy and me dropping a pizza. 🤦🏼‍♂️ They called back and sent another Pizza. ❤️🍕 As a business owner, I appreciate this kind of gesture immensely. 5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐“

“Best Grinders in the world, and I’ve been around at 92. Recently changed hands, better telephone service. Lived nearby for 11 years, now many hours away, but worth the trip, especially after a day of traveling home to take a well wrapped large Italian hot grinder out of the cooler and feast. Stays fresh and tasty.“

“Delicious food. Friendly staff. I'd give them a perfect 5 star rating!“

“I came in about 45 minutes before closing and was met with a smile and friendly greetings. My pizza was done quickly and was hot and delicious. The staff was a step above courteous and I’d certainly eat here again.“

“We ordered 25 pizzas for a work party. They were ready for pick up on time, and the price was very reasonable. The only issue was an employee running her mouth about a local business in the kitchen area loud enough to be heard by customers.“

“We came here in the evening after not preparing adequately to get a reservation for a party of 9…. They were SO accommodating. Sergio, our server, was amazing and super attentive. The food was delicious (especially the siracha bourbon chicken wings, imo) and we had a great experience. Highly recommend!“