Pegasus Coffee House
Customers' Favorites
Pegasus Signature Avocado Toast
Vegetarian Breakfast Bagel
Coffee Drinks and Pastries
Pumpkin Pie Latte
Breakfast Sandwich
Turkey Sandwich
Cinnamon Roll
Vegan Donuts
Coffee Beans
Drip Coffee
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I really loved the exterior of the building 😍! It was pretty busy, with customers constantly coming in and out. You might have to wait a little bit to place your order, but they have both indoor and outdoor seating. The coffee was really good! I ordered 3 coffees. Honestly, I don’t think that’s expensive at all! Overall, I’d definitely recommend checking this place out. The vibe and atmosphere are really nice! ☕✨
On my very first visit to Bainbridge Island, a friend told me to head straight to Pegasus Coffee House, and I am so glad I did! The line around 11 AM on Sunday was about 20 minutes, but with the beautiful weather and zero rush, I was happy to soak it all in. I don't drink caffeine, but their herbal tea selection is excellent. I got the vanilla apple hibiscus tea, and it gave me that rare sensation when something is so incredible you know you might never have it again—11/10....
Love the autumn island vibe from the outside. Service was perfect and the coffee was great also. But my Morning Glory muffin? Delish!!! Tasted like a warm carrot cake. Picked up a bag of coffee to take home also. Approximately $30 for drink, muffin, coffee, and tip. Super reasonable.