Pegasus Coffee House

Customers' Favorites

Photos

+51 photos
+50 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I really loved the exterior of the building 😍! It was pretty busy, with customers constantly coming in and out. You might have to wait a little bit to place your order, but they have both indoor and outdoor seating. The coffee was really good! I ordered 3 coffees. Honestly, I don’t think that’s expensive at all! Overall, I’d definitely recommend checking this place out. The vibe and atmosphere are really nice! ☕✨
On my very first visit to Bainbridge Island, a friend told me to head straight to Pegasus Coffee House, and I am so glad I did! The line around 11 AM on Sunday was about 20 minutes, but with the beautiful weather and zero rush, I was happy to soak it all in. I don't drink caffeine, but their herbal tea selection is excellent. I got the vanilla apple hibiscus tea, and it gave me that rare sensation when something is so incredible you know you might never have it again—11/10....
Love the autumn island vibe from the outside. Service was perfect and the coffee was great also. But my Morning Glory muffin? Delish!!! Tasted like a warm carrot cake. Picked up a bag of coffee to take home also. Approximately $30 for drink, muffin, coffee, and tip. Super reasonable.

More Reviews