Proper Fish
112 Madison Ave N, Bainbridge Island
(206) 855-5051
Customers' Favorites
Fried Oysters and Fish and Chips
Fish and Chips and Clam Chowder
Fried Fish Tacos with Fries
British Fish \u0026 Chips
East Coast Lobster Roll
British Fish No Chips
Proper Fish and Chips
British Fish & Chips
Premium Cod Chowder
Chowder of the Day
Menu
Photos
+73 photos
+72 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Took the ferry over on a Saturday and the line went out to the sidewalk. When we got our food the wait was already 30min. Seating is also limited and they dont allow table saving until you have placed your order so you cant just grab a table while someone stands in line for 30mins. The food is good, nice serving and the kids serving is almost as big. Would go again mid week to avoid the crowds.
Went to Proper Fish after seeing a TikTok video, and it looked so good that we had to try it. After getting off the ferry, we wanted to get away from the immediate crowds, so we kept walking while most people stopped at the shops.
When we got there, it was busy, but we figured everywhere else would probably be just as crowded. I was only about four people away from ordering when the cashier let us know it would be about a 40-minute wait for food. I really appreciated...
When we got there, it was busy, but we figured everywhere else would probably be just as crowded. I was only about four people away from ordering when the cashier let us know it would be about a 40-minute wait for food. I really appreciated...
We enjoyed the food, fish and chips, the fried oysters and the lobster roll were all on point. The downfalls... you had to wait 30 minutes plus after placing your food order and you had to look for your own table. We went back for a second time because the food was simply amazing and worth the wait. The second time was similar as the first with the wait. However, it was not difficult to find a table before the food came out. I would definitely recommend for anyone with a bit of...
You May Also Like
Emmy's Vege House - 100 Winslow Way W
![]()
Vegetarian, Vegan, Asian, Pet Friendly, Gluten-Free
Café Hitchcock - 129 Winslow Way E
![]()
Salad, American, Cocktail Bar, Bar
Sauce Nouvelle - 278 Winslow Way E #109
![]()
American, Soup, Salad, Vegan