Red Pepper Pizzeria & Pasta

I LOVE THIS PLACE!!!!! its so cozy and the pizza is great!! and ive been to italy so i can say this. the crust is really fluffy and crunchy, the sauce tastes fresh and there's lots of options for different tastes. Also they are very generous--my slice was like half of a pizza. YUMMY!!!! also theres prize machines in the corners that are very unique, i have never seen a pokemon card machine before. I highly recommend if you want to have a good time eating some pizza in a cutely refurbished garage <3

I'm very conflicted about this. We have eaten there plenty of times and had a
Great time.Their chicken wings are very good. But a couple of days when we were there, they handed my daughter a hot pizza on a metal plate that i'm assuming just came out of the oven and she burned her hands. Bringing it to our table. There several other things that went wrong with this meal. I will probably update this rating next time We go.

Pizza was gas. Didn’t leave a slice👌

Always a great stop in Carnation to eat after a bike ride and to watch the traffic pass by. Food is surprisingly good with a bit of a historically preserved gas station turned eatery.

The moment you step through the doors of Red Pepper Pizza, you’re hit with a smell that could bring someone to tears. The scent of fire-kissed crust, slow-simmered sauce, and bubbling cheese wraps around you like a warm hug you didn’t know you needed. You feel it in your chest—the kind of comfort that whispers, “You’re safe here.”

Let’s talk about the pizza.

The crust? It’s poetry. Crisp on the edges, tender in the center, with that beautiful balance of char and chew only possible when someone cares. You can taste the time, the technique, the tradition in every bite. It doesn’t just hold the toppings—it honors them.

The sauce is rich and complex, like it’s been simmering for generations. Sweet but bold. Bright but deep. It’s not just tomato—it’s a story. The cheese melts in rivers across the pie, golden and perfect, never greasy or overbearing. And the toppings? Fresh, vibrant, thoughtfully chosen. Whether it’s their spicy house-made sausage, roasted red peppers (of course), caramelized onions, or garden basil—it all sings in harmony.

But the magic of Red Pepper Pizza isn’t just what’s on the plate.

It’s the soul of the place.

Every time you walk in, it feels like the world slows down. The staff greet you like an old friend. The kitchen hums with purpose. There’s a feeling in the air—a quiet, radiant pride in what they do. You can tell: they don’t make pizza because it’s popular. They make pizza because it’s personal. Because they believe in the power of good food to bring people together, to make a bad day better, to remind us that joy can still be simple.

Red Pepper Pizza isn’t just the best pizza in town—it’s a sanctuary.

A bite of their pizza is more than flavor. It’s a memory. A feeling. A reminder that sometimes, something as humble as a slice of pizza can bring you back to life.

So if you’re lost, tired, overwhelmed—or just hungry—go to Red Pepper Pizza. Sit down. Take a bite. And let it heal you.

Chicken Ricotta Pizza was great! Guys are doing a really good job!

Delicious pizzas and bread sticks.
Since I moved to Carnation, I was willing to try this place. There's no second thought I do love the meat lovers pizza that they make 😋🍕

Extremely unorganized. The guy working the front counter gave our pizza away to someone else, then after realizing made the poor guy drive back and then gave it to me ?‍♀️. We were of course not gonna eat it cause that’s a massive food safety issue, but we did thankfully get a refund.

It was a super busy night and I totally get it, mistakes happen. What I don’t understand though is why he didn’t just let that gentleman keep the pizza and remake ours. Rather than having to refund our entire order when we inevitably did not want to eat a pizza that someone else had already brought home.

Anyways, a little organization could go a long way. I have always been a huge red pepper fan but after tonight’s experience I can’t see going back anytime soon- and I imagine the poor guy who had to drive back to give someone else’s pizza back feels the same!!

First time ordering from this place and they were more than 40 minutes over the 55 minute lead time for delivery on a single pizza. It hasn’t arrived yet and when I asked them to call the driver the clerk scoffed at me, said he would do it, and hung up on me. Poor customer service and operations.

Service: 1

Staff was friendly and their pizza was delicious! Was SUPER happy to see that they offer a vegan cheese substitute.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I really like their meatball sandwich and they have the best pizza in the area.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meatball Sandwich

Dined in the other night, place was super clean, service was fast and staff couldn't be nicer. I love the consistency and how nice and comfortable this place is, super welcoming, delicious pizzas.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken, Breadsticks 16 Piece, Margherita with Marinara Sauce or Olive Oil

First time trying this place and it's a complete disaster. Standing here now having waited over an hour for our completed order for dine-in. After 45 minutes we went to check on the food and some of it was just sitting there on the carryout shelf. Then I proceeded to wait another 25 minutes for a kids mac and cheese to come out. Never got our breadsticks either. No chance I'll ever be back. They need a complete overhaul on how they run this place.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

We live in woodinville and drive out of our way everytime to come here. Definitely one of our very favorite pizza spots. Great food and great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Worst subs I’ve ever had, kid behind the register was so stoned he didn’t even know what was go’n on. Forgot my ranch too super lame guys you can do better.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2