So I would rate this a 7.7/7.9 if it was a little crispier but good, on the one bite pizza app.... If you know the scoring that's actually a really good score.... I ordered one cheese and one pepperoni.... I love the pepperoni they use here different from the other places and tasty... Cheese just as good! ? It's not a sit down place it's a take away so that's why I give it a 3.... But yeah service is good and so is the food I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Ann Sappington
Very disappointed with service today. I called in the order and was told food would be ready in 20 to 25 minutes...well one pizza was ready in 30 minutes the second obviously hadn't been made...i had to wait 27 minutes for pizza #2. The one ready as promised was a gluten free crust...it was set on the counter until I asked for it to go under the warmer. So it was cold and cold gluten free is not good. I get it was a busy night...but cook the orders together. And the person up front did not seem to care!
Dietary restrictions: They do have gluten free options
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Cody Lasslett
Pizza is awesome in general, sure, but a pizza has no business being this good! Why is this so delicious? I don't know, but I will be hesitant to get a pizza anywhere else after this.
James woodruff
Hello fresh failed me tonight so I decided to feed the family from Pop's! 4 orders of pasta with salad a small Hawaiian pizza and an extra large 50/50 and a side of garlic bread. This was for 7 hungry people! Pizza was on point hot fresh meaty soft crust family actually asked for it again on pizza night. Each pasta was perfect hot soft noodles perfect sauce flavor (short on salt but happy with that can add more but can't take away) garlic bread was buttery hot and above all garlicky like it's supposed to be. I called them after I placed my order the lady that helped me on the phone was to make sure my order was all there for the delivery person she did amazing! Called back to talk to the manager wasn't there but got her again and wanted to compliment the staff and cooks they are all on point today! Thank you all for the delicious food we will order again 10 out of 10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
slεερү clεσ
Love these guys, I drop by whenever I have the chance and I'm always really happy with both the service and food, which can be hard to do from a shop this small. I've been treated very well by the people employed here and I'll keep coming back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Alfredo
Alan Frank
It's a hidden gem. Make sure you can see the entrance and know where you are going before leaving your car. I had a classic Italian sub that was spectacular!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melinda Simmons
I can't rate service or atmosphere bc we had delivery, but as my son put it "this is cafeteria pizza". If you don't believe me look at the pictures - factory made crust (at the least). We were very hungry. I ate 1/2 a slice. We usually polish off a pizza w/o issue. Gave the 3 star ratings for service & atmosphere to be fair as there is no NA option. The pizza box had no identifiers on it. So maybe the driver switched things up. My husband also ordered a side of marinara that did not come.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Tucker Bane
The "Carbonara" I ordered was not carbonara. It was basically a messy Alfredo soup. The taste was ok, but gave me intestinal issues. So yeah, one star. Also I'm pretty sure it's a ghost kitchen and I'm not a big fan of those
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
Jeremy Wilder
So delicious, they go heavy with the cheese which I love. Lots of good flavor, in the crust and sauce and they cook them enough. I don't know how it compares to the cost of pizza in the area, but it wasn't cheap. I do feel like it was a decent value because it was so delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Kyle Nance
It's a hole in the wall pizza joint, but they make an excellent pizza, do yourself a favor and give them a shot, you won't regret it.
Please make your chefs wear hairnets. I found very short, light hair in my pasta. Both pastas tasted good and were too filling to finish. Bruchetta was soggy and not good. Chocolate cake and baklava were decent.
Andy So
Highly recommend the Federal Way Pizza! Best Pizza spot in town
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Federal Way Pizza
Cereza Bland
Absolutely amazing food! We have ordered a few times through doordash but decided to go in person this time. The food was incredible and super filling! The staff went above and beyond to help us when we misplaced our debit card. The calzones and cannoli are amazing! 12/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy D
I can understand why people like this place it's just not for me. I ordered delivery the other night and was disappointed in my pizza. The toppings come under the cheese which I knew before I ordered but I forgot what this means for pizza quality. When the toppings are under the cheese nothing gets properly cooked or picks up that delicious roasted flavour so it was kind of bland except for the flavour of pizza sauce and uncooked deli meat. I got pepperoni and mushrooms and the mushrooms were wet and the pepperoni had an overwhelming raw pepperoni flavour which was unpleasant. The pizza crust was also undercooked, barely any brown on the bottom so it was floppy and it was a lot thinner than I was expecting for a pizza that isn't advertised to be a thin crust pizza. The sauce is extremely acidic and there was too much of it on the pizza. One the plus side the crust had a nice flavour. The pizza here is also overpriced on all delivery apps so I recommend ordering from this location directly. $25 for a medium pizza with only 6 slices was a hard pill to swallow.
So I would rate this a 7.7/7.9 if it was a little crispier but good, on the one bite pizza app.... If you know the scoring that's actually a really good score.... I ordered one cheese and one pepperoni.... I love the pepperoni they use here different from the other places and tasty... Cheese just as good! ? It's not a sit down place it's a take away so that's why I give it a 3.... But yeah service is good and so is the food I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Very disappointed with service today. I called in the order and was told food would be ready in 20 to 25 minutes...well one pizza was ready in 30 minutes the second obviously hadn't been made...i had to wait 27 minutes for pizza #2. The one ready as promised was a gluten free crust...it was set on the counter until I asked for it to go under the warmer. So it was cold and cold gluten free is not good. I get it was a busy night...but cook the orders together. And the person up front did not seem to care!
Dietary restrictions: They do have gluten free options
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 1
Pizza is awesome in general, sure, but a pizza has no business being this good! Why is this so delicious? I don't know, but I will be hesitant to get a pizza anywhere else after this.
Hello fresh failed me tonight so I decided to feed the family from Pop's! 4 orders of pasta with salad a small Hawaiian pizza and an extra large 50/50 and a side of garlic bread. This was for 7 hungry people! Pizza was on point hot fresh meaty soft crust family actually asked for it again on pizza night. Each pasta was perfect hot soft noodles perfect sauce flavor (short on salt but happy with that can add more but can't take away) garlic bread was buttery hot and above all garlicky like it's supposed to be. I called them after I placed my order the lady that helped me on the phone was to make sure my order was all there for the delivery person she did amazing! Called back to talk to the manager wasn't there but got her again and wanted to compliment the staff and cooks they are all on point today! Thank you all for the delicious food we will order again 10 out of 10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love these guys, I drop by whenever I have the chance and I'm always really happy with both the service and food, which can be hard to do from a shop this small. I've been treated very well by the people employed here and I'll keep coming back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Alfredo
It's a hidden gem. Make sure you can see the entrance and know where you are going before leaving your car. I had a classic Italian sub that was spectacular!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
I can't rate service or atmosphere bc we had delivery, but as my son put it "this is cafeteria pizza". If you don't believe me look at the pictures - factory made crust (at the least). We were very hungry. I ate 1/2 a slice. We usually polish off a pizza w/o issue. Gave the 3 star ratings for service & atmosphere to be fair as there is no NA option. The pizza box had no identifiers on it. So maybe the driver switched things up. My husband also ordered a side of marinara that did not come.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
The "Carbonara" I ordered was not carbonara. It was basically a messy Alfredo soup. The taste was ok, but gave me intestinal issues. So yeah, one star.
Also I'm pretty sure it's a ghost kitchen and I'm not a big fan of those
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 3
So delicious, they go heavy with the cheese which I love. Lots of good flavor, in the crust and sauce and they cook them enough. I don't know how it compares to the cost of pizza in the area, but it wasn't cheap. I do feel like it was a decent value because it was so delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
It's a hole in the wall pizza joint, but they make an excellent pizza, do yourself a favor and give them a shot, you won't regret it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Omg, lived in federal for 4 years and just found this place. It’s AMAZING! Don’t delay, order today
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread, Pepperoni Pizza, Baklava
Please make your chefs wear hairnets. I found very short, light hair in my pasta. Both pastas tasted good and were too filling to finish. Bruchetta was soggy and not good. Chocolate cake and baklava were decent.
Highly recommend the Federal Way Pizza! Best Pizza spot in town
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Federal Way Pizza
Absolutely amazing food! We have ordered a few times through doordash but decided to go in person this time. The food was incredible and super filling! The staff went above and beyond to help us when we misplaced our debit card. The calzones and cannoli are amazing! 12/10
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I can understand why people like this place it's just not for me. I ordered delivery the other night and was disappointed in my pizza. The toppings come under the cheese which I knew before I ordered but I forgot what this means for pizza quality. When the toppings are under the cheese nothing gets properly cooked or picks up that delicious roasted flavour so it was kind of bland except for the flavour of pizza sauce and uncooked deli meat. I got pepperoni and mushrooms and the mushrooms were wet and the pepperoni had an overwhelming raw pepperoni flavour which was unpleasant. The pizza crust was also undercooked, barely any brown on the bottom so it was floppy and it was a lot thinner than I was expecting for a pizza that isn't advertised to be a thin crust pizza. The sauce is extremely acidic and there was too much of it on the pizza. One the plus side the crust had a nice flavour. The pizza here is also overpriced on all delivery apps so I recommend ordering from this location directly. $25 for a medium pizza with only 6 slices was a hard pill to swallow.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Loading...