I come to Seattle several times a year but somehow never realized Pagliacci Pizza was a thing, so on this most recent visit, I gave it a try.It was a clean store with lots of bright outdoor light from the windows. Smaller interior for seating but it looked like most of the people who came in did so for takeout, and there was lots of seating when I got there to get my order.Their Sicilian chicken salad has a nice little spice too it and was packed with chicken and other ingredients, so getting a balanced bite of everything was easy. I love a good salad where there are enough portions of all the ingredients.What I loved the most though was their pizza by the slice bar! I really just wanted a couple pieces of pizza, and I love that the slice menu meant I could get two pizza types. The Tricolore pizza was definitely my favorite, but I'm such a sucker for pesto, so your mileage will vary. The other pizza slice was the Diavola, which was also pretty good.Each slice plus the salad was more than enough for one meal for me (although to be fair, I'm not often able to eat as much as I used to). It's a nice thin and flavorful crust and toppings.Also, in full disclosure, the second main reason I chose this pizza place over a few others I was considering (the first main reason was the pizza by the slice) was because of the Squatch labeling. 10/10 labeling art.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salads, Small Salad, Pizza by the Slice of Pie
Baron Saturday
Very tasty pizza ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
joe jonart
whether it's phone in orders (where you can actually talk to a person), or drop in for a slice. The service is top notch, most of the employees look like they are happy to be there and to have a job, and I think that shows. The food is always so consistent and delicious. This is the only "chain" pizza place my family and I enjoy on a consistent basis. I've done dine in, take out and delivery. It's all excellent. Thanks Pags!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Cheese Pizza, Our Pizza, Pagliaci Salad, Salads, Pepperoni Pizza and Pesto Pasta Salad, Small Salad, Double Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Pizza by the Slice of Pie, Extra Pepperoni Pizza
Cheryl Altschuler
Very good selection of pizza. They have slices. Very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Our Pizza, Pizza by the Slice of Pie
Paul Cullen
Eat-in pizza by the slice was served cold. No offer made to heat it.
Sometimes good, sometimes overcooked, sometimes incorrect. Service isn't what it used to be. Make sure you're waiting on the store when your takeout order is ready - had several cold orders. Our weekly spot for a long time, but had to switch.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Sugarplum Fairy
Pizza is pricey but delicious. I actually order here because of the salads which are really good! Last time I got my husband a calzone and he loved it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Our Pizza, Great Calzone the Way You Like It, Salads, Pizza by the Slice of Pie, Extra Pepperoni Pizza
Cassandra P
I haven’t had Pagliacci’s in years and knew it was a must while visiting from Texas this time around. I remember the pizza being phenomenal and used to eat it all the time before having to go Gluten Free. The GF pizza crust is PHENOMENAL . We ordered a GF extra pepperoni, a regular 11 Hawaiian and a customized Calzone. We’d love to see Pagliacci’s in Texas.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Calzone the Way You Like It
shantel thao
Only gotten pizza by the slice, and for the price, it is good overall. Definitely one of the better by the slice pizzas especially in the Kenmore area.
Yummy gelato, friendly staff, and pizza with the right combo of chewy and crispy crust. This time, I got the Burrata Soppreesata which has mild pork salami, soft burrata cheese, and fresh tomatoes fished with arugula after baking. Overall it was delicious except for a few unripe fresh tomatoes. The Gelatiamo peppermint gelato was super minty just how I like it. If you're a person who wishes things were mintier, this gelato is for you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Dia Cote
Pagliacci's is fabulous for their food, but the prices could use to come a wee bit closer to earth; they are steep. If they could lower their prices some, more people could afford to purchase it and they would quite possibly have more customers.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Our Pizza, Salads
Devon
I have 2 requests.1.Please let me place an order over the phone without paying over the phone. I'm usually driving and pulling over defeats the convenience of ordering.2. Please let me build a pie out of the available slices. I often show up right before you close (I work late), I'd build a pie out of the remaining slices. You can charge me for the most expensive slice at the pie price. It lets you get some more fresh pizza going during the day and allows people that are limited on time to still grab a whole pie.I love your product, but could use those 2 things to be perfect. Cheers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Rebecca Davis (Buggy)
A Seattle area legend. The pizza is so very crispy. The toppings are great and there’s always a seasonal pizza and gelato. There’s always at least one non meat option. A very nice gentleman helped me and was so personable.Vegetarian options: Always at least one option
I come to Seattle several times a year but somehow never realized Pagliacci Pizza was a thing, so on this most recent visit, I gave it a try.It was a clean store with lots of bright outdoor light from the windows. Smaller interior for seating but it looked like most of the people who came in did so for takeout, and there was lots of seating when I got there to get my order.Their Sicilian chicken salad has a nice little spice too it and was packed with chicken and other ingredients, so getting a balanced bite of everything was easy. I love a good salad where there are enough portions of all the ingredients.What I loved the most though was their pizza by the slice bar! I really just wanted a couple pieces of pizza, and I love that the slice menu meant I could get two pizza types. The Tricolore pizza was definitely my favorite, but I'm such a sucker for pesto, so your mileage will vary. The other pizza slice was the Diavola, which was also pretty good.Each slice plus the salad was more than enough for one meal for me (although to be fair, I'm not often able to eat as much as I used to). It's a nice thin and flavorful crust and toppings.Also, in full disclosure, the second main reason I chose this pizza place over a few others I was considering (the first main reason was the pizza by the slice) was because of the Squatch labeling. 10/10 labeling art.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salads, Small Salad, Pizza by the Slice of Pie
Very tasty pizza ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
whether it's phone in orders (where you can actually talk to a person), or drop in for a slice. The service is top notch, most of the employees look like they are happy to be there and to have a job, and I think that shows. The food is always so consistent and delicious. This is the only "chain" pizza place my family and I enjoy on a consistent basis. I've done dine in, take out and delivery. It's all excellent. Thanks Pags!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Cheese Pizza, Our Pizza, Pagliaci Salad, Salads, Pepperoni Pizza and Pesto Pasta Salad, Small Salad, Double Pepperoni Pizza Slice, Pizza by the Slice of Pie, Extra Pepperoni Pizza
Very good selection of pizza. They have slices. Very friendly.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Our Pizza, Pizza by the Slice of Pie
Eat-in pizza by the slice was served cold. No offer made to heat it.
That was great no more
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Spicy Chicken Pizza, Cheese Pizza
Sometimes good, sometimes overcooked, sometimes incorrect. Service isn't what it used to be. Make sure you're waiting on the store when your takeout order is ready - had several cold orders. Our weekly spot for a long time, but had to switch.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 2
Pizza is pricey but delicious. I actually order here because of the salads which are really good! Last time I got my husband a calzone and he loved it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Our Pizza, Great Calzone the Way You Like It, Salads, Pizza by the Slice of Pie, Extra Pepperoni Pizza
I haven’t had Pagliacci’s in years and knew it was a must while visiting from Texas this time around. I remember the pizza being phenomenal and used to eat it all the time before having to go Gluten Free. The GF pizza crust is PHENOMENAL . We ordered a GF extra pepperoni, a regular 11 Hawaiian and a customized Calzone. We’d love to see Pagliacci’s in Texas.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Calzone the Way You Like It
Only gotten pizza by the slice, and for the price, it is good overall. Definitely one of the better by the slice pizzas especially in the Kenmore area.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza, loved the thin, crispy crust.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Double Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Yummy gelato, friendly staff, and pizza with the right combo of chewy and crispy crust. This time, I got the Burrata Soppreesata which has mild pork salami, soft burrata cheese, and fresh tomatoes fished with arugula after baking. Overall it was delicious except for a few unripe fresh tomatoes. The Gelatiamo peppermint gelato was super minty just how I like it. If you're a person who wishes things were mintier, this gelato is for you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Pagliacci's is fabulous for their food, but the prices could use to come a wee bit closer to earth; they are steep. If they could lower their prices some, more people could afford to purchase it and they would quite possibly have more customers.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Our Pizza, Salads
I have 2 requests.1.Please let me place an order over the phone without paying over the phone. I'm usually driving and pulling over defeats the convenience of ordering.2. Please let me build a pie out of the available slices. I often show up right before you close (I work late), I'd build a pie out of the remaining slices. You can charge me for the most expensive slice at the pie price. It lets you get some more fresh pizza going during the day and allows people that are limited on time to still grab a whole pie.I love your product, but could use those 2 things to be perfect. Cheers!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
A Seattle area legend. The pizza is so very crispy. The toppings are great and there’s always a seasonal pizza and gelato. There’s always at least one non meat option. A very nice gentleman helped me and was so personable.Vegetarian options: Always at least one option
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Our Pizza, Pagliaci Salad, Autumn Harvest, Pear Gorgonzola Pizza, Small Salad