It’s soggy slop, I don’t believe for a second that this is wood fired pizza. You pick up a slice, and good luck keeping the toppings on. I asked for well done, not even close. Sorry if this comes across as harsh, but for $54 for a large with 1 extra topping along with salty wings, I’m going to be critical. I’m aware that a cardboard box doesn’t do a pizza well, but they’ve got something else going on. Maybe try changing up the dough recipe? Cheap cheese used too, very disappointing.
James Marek
I was really looking forward to finding a new favorite pizza spot with my first visit here. Unfortunately, the experience fell a bit short of my expectations. The crust was quite soggy and undercooked, which made the toppings slide off easily. For the price—over $100 for three pizzas and a 10-piece order of wings—I was hoping for a more satisfying meal. That said, I’m willing to give this place another try and will request that the pizzas be cooked a bit longer next time. I’m hopeful that a slight adjustment could make a big difference!
Cassandra Hofferber
Amazing Pizza! Can order by the slice, for dine-in (seating is limited, but we didn't have too much trouble finding a spot) or take-out. Will absolutely be eating here again.
Tony Atkins
Pizza was awful
Clover Fultz
First off awesome taste in music. Great service! The pizza is delicious the crust it perfectly crunchy, cheese pull is there, and the pepperoni is nice and crisp! Plenty of drinks selection! Overall loved it would go again!
Jose Luis Avila Castillo (Don Palabras)
We ordered the meat lovers version and Parmesan wings, middle of the week for dinner. The pizza did not taste at all like wood fired, the dough was saggy and chewy to a degree. Not the wood fired texture and flavor you would expect. The wings were pretty good. Overall a decent pizza.
Drita D'Alessandro
Good Pizza, not great service.
I'm from Michigan, where it's pretty normal to go in to pizza places for just a slice and have them warm it up in front of the fire.
When the guy at the counter gave me my slice I ordered and I asked him to warm it up, he said no. Maybe that's not a normal ask here, but I was also the only person in the shop. So I don't feel like warming it in front of the fire for 5 seconds would have been the end of the world.
Especially as the slice was Luke want and the cheese wasn't melted.
Melissa Daigle
Pizza was pretty good!
Tanya Gross
This pizza joint used to be my favorite one in town. I even had them on my contact list. I have not ordered for a while, but I decided to tonight because I had company and I bragged about the pizzas.
However, when I received the pizza, it was not how it used to be. One of my favorite chicken, bacon ranch pizzas was crap. The onions uncooked and had large, raw slices of tomatoes on top. you couldn’t taste the ranch at all and very little chicken pieces or bacon pieces. It was tasteless. I am very disappointed in what I got probably will not order from there ever again. Even the chicken wings weren’t what they used to be. I ordered sweet chili sauce, chicken wings, and got something like buffalo and red pepper flakes. . So hot I could not even eat one full wing. Nothing sweet about it. Not happy!
Anna Lyons
The cheese is salty, the bread is chewy and the sauce is perfect. Best cheese pizza in Poulsbo!
Kid-friendliness: Always take my kids here, they love it (very picky). Staff is super nice and accommodating.
Great food, we loved everything. Try their foods if you ever find yourself in the beautiful city of Poulsbo. I know I will come back to this place for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken, Pepperoni and Sausage, Fries
Patti O
We came to grab dinner before a game in Poulsbo and this was easily one of the best pizza's we've had. Cozy indoors on a cold evening with the aroma of pizza and wood fire, view of waterfront. We got a simple medium double pepperoni with pepperoncini. It was more than enough for two. Smokey flavor of crust was distinctive and delicious! I saw many other things on menu I'd love to try next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Bret Black
Totally screwed up my order. Pizza was wrong and undercooked. This place is not what it used to be. I doubt i will go back
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Tim Phariss
Can't judge service or atmosphere as it was a pickup. The sausage-pepperoni was sparse with a tough crust, the Mediterranean had a good amount of artichoke with a better crust.
Food: 3
Richard Eshelman
Delicious fresh all around pizza. Eating outside on the deck is a bonus.
It’s soggy slop, I don’t believe for a second that this is wood fired pizza. You pick up a slice, and good luck keeping the toppings on. I asked for well done, not even close. Sorry if this comes across as harsh, but for $54 for a large with 1 extra topping along with salty wings, I’m going to be critical. I’m aware that a cardboard box doesn’t do a pizza well, but they’ve got something else going on. Maybe try changing up the dough recipe? Cheap cheese used too, very disappointing.
I was really looking forward to finding a new favorite pizza spot with my first visit here. Unfortunately, the experience fell a bit short of my expectations. The crust was quite soggy and undercooked, which made the toppings slide off easily. For the price—over $100 for three pizzas and a 10-piece order of wings—I was hoping for a more satisfying meal.
That said, I’m willing to give this place another try and will request that the pizzas be cooked a bit longer next time. I’m hopeful that a slight adjustment could make a big difference!
Amazing Pizza! Can order by the slice, for dine-in (seating is limited, but we didn't have too much trouble finding a spot) or take-out. Will absolutely be eating here again.
Pizza was awful
First off awesome taste in music. Great service! The pizza is delicious the crust it perfectly crunchy, cheese pull is there, and the pepperoni is nice and crisp! Plenty of drinks selection! Overall loved it would go again!
We ordered the meat lovers version and Parmesan wings, middle of the week for dinner. The pizza did not taste at all like wood fired, the dough was saggy and chewy to a degree. Not the wood fired texture and flavor you would expect. The wings were pretty good. Overall a decent pizza.
Good Pizza, not great service.
I'm from Michigan, where it's pretty normal to go in to pizza places for just a slice and have them warm it up in front of the fire.
When the guy at the counter gave me my slice I ordered and I asked him to warm it up, he said no. Maybe that's not a normal ask here, but I was also the only person in the shop. So I don't feel like warming it in front of the fire for 5 seconds would have been the end of the world.
Especially as the slice was Luke want and the cheese wasn't melted.
Pizza was pretty good!
This pizza joint used to be my favorite one in town. I even had them on my contact list. I have not ordered for a while, but I decided to tonight because I had company and I bragged about the pizzas. However, when I received the pizza, it was not how it used to be. One of my favorite chicken, bacon ranch pizzas was crap. The onions uncooked and had large, raw slices of tomatoes on top. you couldn’t taste the ranch at all and very little chicken pieces or bacon pieces. It was tasteless. I am very disappointed in what I got probably will not order from there ever again. Even the chicken wings weren’t what they used to be. I ordered sweet chili sauce, chicken wings, and got something like buffalo and red pepper flakes. . So hot I could not even eat one full wing. Nothing sweet about it. Not happy!
The cheese is salty, the bread is chewy and the sauce is perfect. Best cheese pizza in Poulsbo!
Kid-friendliness: Always take my kids here, they love it (very picky). Staff is super nice and accommodating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food, we loved everything. Try their foods if you ever find yourself in the beautiful city of Poulsbo. I know I will come back to this place for sure.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: BBQ Chicken, Pepperoni and Sausage, Fries
We came to grab dinner before a game in Poulsbo and this was easily one of the best pizza's we've had. Cozy indoors on a cold evening with the aroma of pizza and wood fire, view of waterfront. We got a simple medium double pepperoni with pepperoncini. It was more than enough for two. Smokey flavor of crust was distinctive and delicious! I saw many other things on menu I'd love to try next time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Totally screwed up my order. Pizza was wrong and undercooked. This place is not what it used to be. I doubt i will go back
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Can't judge service or atmosphere as it was a pickup. The sausage-pepperoni was sparse with a tough crust, the Mediterranean had a good amount of artichoke with a better crust.
Food: 3
Delicious fresh all around pizza. Eating outside on the deck is a bonus.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Herbivore Pizza
Loading...