Jersey Mike's Subs in Puyallup

“I came in at about 8:30 tonight. There were 2 younger guys working, I didn’t get any names but one had long hair in a pony and the other maybe been Filipino or Pacific Islander . As soon as I walked in they were both so attentive and greeted me immediately. They made me feel like they legit wanted me in there- it was very refreshing especially because I knew I came in right before closing and everyone usually hates those people lol. My sandwich was beyond perfect, tastes like Mike himself made it and the 2 guys were so cool and funny.“

“I come to this Jersey Mike’s all the time since I work nearby, and they’re always great. I usually order through the app, and my food is always ready when I get there. Everyone is super friendly, and today’s experience was especially awesome. Andrew took the time to help me track down a receipt I had lost, and I really appreciated him going the extra mile to help. Thanks again!“

“After reading the reviews left for this Jersey Mike’s location and being shocked I have to leave my review. I’m not sure why this location is rated so low. I’ve been treated so well here that I’ve become a regular. I’ve never had any problems with the customer service that I’ve received or with my sandwich. In fact I’d say each and every time I go they have gone above and beyond for me. Yes it’s a lot of kids working there and sometimes it’s new people being trained and I’ve still never had a bad experience. Don’t let these bad reviews run you away. Maybe it’s an entirely new crew now. I’m not sure. But I haven’t had a bad experience yet. The place is always clean and the line at lunch time always moves fast. My sandwich is always made the way I like it and taste amazing every single time.“