It’s almost 2 am, I’m ripping thee ole Pennifer Gardner, and I can’t stop thinking about their Italian. Truly a feat of Sandwich engineering. In my time between Seattle, New Orleans, and Boston I have never had a better Italian sandwich. This is a sandwich you write home to mom about.
Daniel Ritchie
Ordered the chicken pesto - definitely one of the better sandwiches I've had. Staff were friendly, bathroom was clean, water was cold, and the outdoor seating was lovely on the sunny day I visited.
Mili Shah
Very nice outdoor seating. Staff was extremely friendly. They had lots of options for vegetarians and were very accommodating with customizations.
Kelsey M
Some of the best sandwiches in the city. I have never seen them not busy. You will have to wait 10-15 minutes for your sandwich during peak time because these sandwiches are REGAL and take time to make. They have (canned/bottled) beer available as well. Seating is extremely limited inside, but there's more outdoor seating for when it's nice out. They have wifi available, password is posted near the register. The crew is awesome; very friendly and always seem happy to be feeding the masses, and they always have great tunes playing. I always try to give a little joy back to them by leaving a pun or dad joke at the bottom of our online order, and they always reciprocate :)
Jennifer M.
Small sandwich shop with delicious food. Friendly staff promptly took my order and called me when it was done. Maybe one of the best Italian sandwiches I’ve ever had.
Abhishek Deshmukh
The Italian grinder and pesto chicken are some of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had!
Kaitlyn
Exceptional bread. The Italian grinder was exactly what I was craving.
Derrick Morse
Great sandwiches, and friendly staff. Definitely worth the stop.
Hanna B
Had a great experience here. I got a sandwich to go, so I can’t speak to the seating or etc. The staff were so accommodating and sweet. I’m Muslim, so I don’t eat pork, and it was lovely the way they were willing to accommodate my food preferences + generally pickiness. The sandwich I got was delicious, reasonably priced, and very much worth the wait. I’ll be coming back here again.
Matt Madia
The sandwich was good. But DEFINITELY NOT a panini. They don't offer what I would call a panini. And shockingly expensive. Damn near $20 for a mid sized sandwich and a cup of water. I felt like I got less than what I paid for.
A few indoor seats at a window bar and more outside, filtered water pump, and dog-friendly. The staff are lovely, really friendly folks, honestly can't hype them enough.
The food is fine. Huge bread rolls that aren't particularly great but also not particularly terrible, absolutely average fillings, completely fine preparation.
I don't think I'll go again simply because it was a solid whatever in a city full of fantastic options.
My group got one standard (non-vegan) sandwich and one vegan one, both were equally mid.
Lizzie M
I thought this was a good place. The service is really great & we didn’t have to wait too long. The sandwich (Italian) had the perfect vinegar ratio with all the pickled toppings, peppers, and such. I LOVED that it came toasted and was a reasonable size.
I feel like a lot of sandwich shops that I’ve been to take 40+ mins, but we got lucky going on a Sunday around 1:30pm. Not too much seating but enough to squeeze 2-3 folks. There’s outdoor seating which is probably better for the warmer weather. But a good vibe all around.
Also I might add that - even though the sandwich is a little pricey, it was even in flavor and size and worth the ~$16-$19. I didn’t feel robbed at all.
Bleh Blah
Don't sleep on this outrageously good sandwich shop!
Emily Carman
Really good, warm sandwiches made fresh! The inside is small but it’s a vibe with lots of funny signs up. And the staff is really friendly. You will have to wait for your sandwich, but that’s how you know it’s made fresh! Would definitely come again to try different sandwiches.
Andrew Shifflette
These sandwiches are delicious. Can't recommend them enough. Bonus the staff go above and beyond to make you feel welcome. Thank you. I will be coming back!
It’s almost 2 am, I’m ripping thee ole Pennifer Gardner, and I can’t stop thinking about their Italian. Truly a feat of Sandwich engineering. In my time between Seattle, New Orleans, and Boston I have never had a better Italian sandwich. This is a sandwich you write home to mom about.
Ordered the chicken pesto - definitely one of the better sandwiches I've had. Staff were friendly, bathroom was clean, water was cold, and the outdoor seating was lovely on the sunny day I visited.
Very nice outdoor seating. Staff was extremely friendly. They had lots of options for vegetarians and were very accommodating with customizations.
Some of the best sandwiches in the city. I have never seen them not busy. You will have to wait 10-15 minutes for your sandwich during peak time because these sandwiches are REGAL and take time to make. They have (canned/bottled) beer available as well. Seating is extremely limited inside, but there's more outdoor seating for when it's nice out. They have wifi available, password is posted near the register. The crew is awesome; very friendly and always seem happy to be feeding the masses, and they always have great tunes playing. I always try to give a little joy back to them by leaving a pun or dad joke at the bottom of our online order, and they always reciprocate :)
Small sandwich shop with delicious food.
Friendly staff promptly took my order and called me when it was done.
Maybe one of the best Italian sandwiches I’ve ever had.
The Italian grinder and pesto chicken are some of the best sandwiches I’ve ever had!
Exceptional bread. The Italian grinder was exactly what I was craving.
Great sandwiches, and friendly staff. Definitely worth the stop.
Had a great experience here. I got a sandwich to go, so I can’t speak to the seating or etc. The staff were so accommodating and sweet. I’m Muslim, so I don’t eat pork, and it was lovely the way they were willing to accommodate my food preferences + generally pickiness. The sandwich I got was delicious, reasonably priced, and very much worth the wait. I’ll be coming back here again.
The sandwich was good. But DEFINITELY NOT a panini. They don't offer what I would call a panini. And shockingly expensive. Damn near $20 for a mid sized sandwich and a cup of water. I felt like I got less than what I paid for.
Restaurantji Recommends
A few indoor seats at a window bar and more outside, filtered water pump, and dog-friendly. The staff are lovely, really friendly folks, honestly can't hype them enough. The food is fine. Huge bread rolls that aren't particularly great but also not particularly terrible, absolutely average fillings, completely fine preparation. I don't think I'll go again simply because it was a solid whatever in a city full of fantastic options. My group got one standard (non-vegan) sandwich and one vegan one, both were equally mid.
I thought this was a good place. The service is really great & we didn’t have to wait too long. The sandwich (Italian) had the perfect vinegar ratio with all the pickled toppings, peppers, and such. I LOVED that it came toasted and was a reasonable size.
I feel like a lot of sandwich shops that I’ve been to take 40+ mins, but we got lucky going on a Sunday around 1:30pm. Not too much seating but enough to squeeze 2-3 folks. There’s outdoor seating which is probably better for the warmer weather. But a good vibe all around.
Also I might add that - even though the sandwich is a little pricey, it was even in flavor and size and worth the ~$16-$19. I didn’t feel robbed at all.
Don't sleep on this outrageously good sandwich shop!
Really good, warm sandwiches made fresh! The inside is small but it’s a vibe with lots of funny signs up. And the staff is really friendly. You will have to wait for your sandwich, but that’s how you know it’s made fresh! Would definitely come again to try different sandwiches.
These sandwiches are delicious. Can't recommend them enough. Bonus the staff go above and beyond to make you feel welcome. Thank you. I will be coming back!
Loading...