Connected to the bar inside, Stevie's Famous pizza is by far the best New York slice I have had in Seattle. Quality ingredients, and thoughtful pizzas, this place absolutely is a must go to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Normie MacDonald Pizza
Samtsung Cohen
One of the top 3 slices in Seattle.To me, in order of importance to a slice's success is it's crust, it's cheese, it's sauce and then at a very tiny distant 4th place is its toppings.Stevie's crust is the star, rather sourdoughy and densely chewy. Somewhere in the NYC Slice - Neopolitan range. Intense char on the crust says Neopolitan played some influence. Very impressive, especially in this city of floppy dough.Cheese was acceptable, but needs the most love. A bit scant, but flavorful. This is one of those slices where you have a lot of no cheese bites. Maybe it's to let the crust and sauce shine, but I would have preferred a bit more coverage. Maybe one of their other types of pizza has a more solid covering, will definitely try again.Sauce was awesome. Heavy on the sour rich end, not a hint of sugar detected. That plus the chunks of Parm made this a super savory experience. Unfortunately this was a bit light on sauce as well as cheese. Yes this makes the crust shine, but there were certainly a few sundried tomato tart like bites.Finally beyond the fundamentals, the topping of pepperoni was a bit scant. About 7 of the little upturned cup types on a slice. Nicely singed.$6.5 a slice strikes me as absurd, but I'll be back. Someone mentioned these are large slices, they are definitely not. They are exactly average size slices - 1/8 of a 16" pie.TLDR - best crust in Seattle maybe? But a bit skimpy on cheese sauce and toppings and not cheap on price.But if it's quality you care about, you'll still love Stevies even with its detractions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Russell Berry
Great new pizza joint on Beacon. Not that I need another reason to go to the Clockout..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Victor T.
I had to try the pizza named after Norm MacDonald. It was legit. Delicious crust, fresh-tasting sauce, nice and thin, but not floppy. Go get yourself a pie!
Claire M.
I appreciated how beautifully charred the bottom of the pizza is, leaving a delightful and delicious mineral taste lingering in my mouth, even as I write this review an hour later. I ordered 4 slices Cheese, Normie MacDonald, Pepperoni and the the daily special with pesto, aged mozzarella, red onion and hot honey. The hot honey is not to be missed. I felt the wait time fit how busy it was and I am sure it gets busier than what I witnessed but I would say it's totally worth it. I have always enjoyed Clock Out Lounge, before 8 pm means the environment is more chill after 8pm a show might be starting so just be prepared for a shift to a strictly bar scene.
Jason Lam (STYRKE Games)
Got the Normies pizza it was good, but they forgot the burrata that was suppose to come with it, and the only reason I got that pizza was to try out the burrata, the pizza smelled amazing and tasted good for my tastebud which is something to say because I get disappointed at everything I eat. Took off a star because they forgot what I thought would be the main ingredient. Wish they had pineapple :) for me to add on to a pepperoni pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Normie MacDonald Pizza
Paul Fick
Some of the best pizza in town. Slices are huge, two are plenty unless you’re really, really hungry. Great new addition to the ClockOut.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mathis S.
This was ridiculous. We waited for 1 1/2 hours before getting our pizza. They totally truely suck monkeyballz. The pizza that we recieved was BURNT!
Blake Pool
By far the closest NYC crust I've found in Seattle. The flavors and ingredients were top notch. The toppings were spread in a way that it seemed they cared. Highly recommend the Normie MacDonald, the hot honey is yummy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hayden Jackson
If the Christ himself came back, he’d stop in for a Pie before all the saving.
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Build Your Own Red Pie, Red Sauce
Pablo Morales
Seattle has a new pizza heavyweight im town! For me personally this is tied with Post Alley Pizza for my favorite pizza if this style in the city. Yes, I really miss Breezy Town, but this pizza is just too damn good.
Food: 5
Nick Anderson
Amazing pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Brendan Bosworth
Stevie’s rules
Kylene Wolfe
Good Chicago style pizza, particularly liked the crust!
Connected to the bar inside, Stevie's Famous pizza is by far the best New York slice I have had in Seattle. Quality ingredients, and thoughtful pizzas, this place absolutely is a must go to.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Normie MacDonald Pizza
One of the top 3 slices in Seattle.To me, in order of importance to a slice's success is it's crust, it's cheese, it's sauce and then at a very tiny distant 4th place is its toppings.Stevie's crust is the star, rather sourdoughy and densely chewy. Somewhere in the NYC Slice - Neopolitan range. Intense char on the crust says Neopolitan played some influence. Very impressive, especially in this city of floppy dough.Cheese was acceptable, but needs the most love. A bit scant, but flavorful. This is one of those slices where you have a lot of no cheese bites. Maybe it's to let the crust and sauce shine, but I would have preferred a bit more coverage. Maybe one of their other types of pizza has a more solid covering, will definitely try again.Sauce was awesome. Heavy on the sour rich end, not a hint of sugar detected. That plus the chunks of Parm made this a super savory experience. Unfortunately this was a bit light on sauce as well as cheese. Yes this makes the crust shine, but there were certainly a few sundried tomato tart like bites.Finally beyond the fundamentals, the topping of pepperoni was a bit scant. About 7 of the little upturned cup types on a slice. Nicely singed.$6.5 a slice strikes me as absurd, but I'll be back. Someone mentioned these are large slices, they are definitely not. They are exactly average size slices - 1/8 of a 16" pie.TLDR - best crust in Seattle maybe? But a bit skimpy on cheese sauce and toppings and not cheap on price.But if it's quality you care about, you'll still love Stevies even with its detractions.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great new pizza joint on Beacon. Not that I need another reason to go to the Clockout..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had to try the pizza named after Norm MacDonald. It was legit. Delicious crust, fresh-tasting sauce, nice and thin, but not floppy. Go get yourself a pie!
I appreciated how beautifully charred the bottom of the pizza is, leaving a delightful and delicious mineral taste lingering in my mouth, even as I write this review an hour later. I ordered 4 slices Cheese, Normie MacDonald, Pepperoni and the the daily special with pesto, aged mozzarella, red onion and hot honey. The hot honey is not to be missed. I felt the wait time fit how busy it was and I am sure it gets busier than what I witnessed but I would say it's totally worth it. I have always enjoyed Clock Out Lounge, before 8 pm means the environment is more chill after 8pm a show might be starting so just be prepared for a shift to a strictly bar scene.
Got the Normies pizza it was good, but they forgot the burrata that was suppose to come with it, and the only reason I got that pizza was to try out the burrata, the pizza smelled amazing and tasted good for my tastebud which is something to say because I get disappointed at everything I eat. Took off a star because they forgot what I thought would be the main ingredient. Wish they had pineapple :) for me to add on to a pepperoni pizza.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Normie MacDonald Pizza
Some of the best pizza in town. Slices are huge, two are plenty unless you’re really, really hungry. Great new addition to the ClockOut.
Food: 5
Service: 5
This was ridiculous. We waited for 1 1/2 hours before getting our pizza. They totally truely suck monkeyballz. The pizza that we recieved was BURNT!
By far the closest NYC crust I've found in Seattle. The flavors and ingredients were top notch. The toppings were spread in a way that it seemed they cared. Highly recommend the Normie MacDonald, the hot honey is yummy.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
If the Christ himself came back, he’d stop in for a Pie before all the saving.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Normie MacDonald Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing pizza with efficient online ordering.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Build Your Own Red Pie, Red Sauce
Seattle has a new pizza heavyweight im town! For me personally this is tied with Post Alley Pizza for my favorite pizza if this style in the city. Yes, I really miss Breezy Town, but this pizza is just too damn good.
Food: 5
Amazing pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stevie’s rules
Good Chicago style pizza, particularly liked the crust!