West of Chicago Pizza Company

3770 SW Alaska St, Seattle
(206) 339-3337

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Pepperoni Sausage Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
Italian Beef Tavern Style Pizza
Build Your Own Thin Crust Pizza
Breadsticks with Cheese Sauce
Build Your Own Deep Dish Pie
Sausage Tavern Thin Pizza
Italian Beef Sandwich
The Original Pizza
Meatball Parmesan
Mama's Meatball

Menu

Thin Crust
Italian Beef Pizza
Seasoned Italian beef, giardiniera (vito and nick's did it first, but that's because we weren't around yet!!)
Build Your Own Thin Crust Pizza
go wild! but remember 3 toppings is the max! you want it thin right??

9'' Deep Dish Pizza(no preorder for dine in please)
The Original (9")
pizzas don't get cut. Serves 2-3. Sausage, pepperoni, caramelized onion (no substitutions)
The Pisano (9")
pizzas don't get cut. 2-3. Sausage, roasted garlic, broccoli(no substitutions)
The Antichrist (9")
pizzas don't get cut. Serves 2-3. Capicola, pineapple(no substitutions)
The Plethora (9")
pizzas don't get cut. Serves 2-3. Pepperoni, Gr. Pepper, pepperoncini, Mama Lil's peppers(no substitutions)
The Tree Hugger (9")
pizzas don't get cut. Serves 2-3. Roasted garlic, mushroom, spinach, artichoke(no substitutions)
The Bay Area (9")
pizzas don't get cut. Serves 2-3. Chicken, bacon, spinach(no substitutions)
The Superfan (9")
pizzas don't get cut. Serves 2-3. Pepperoni, Sausage, Gr. Pepper, 'shrooms, black olives(no substitutions)
Mama's Meatball (9")
pizzas don't get cut. Serves 2-3. Meatballs, garlic, ricotta, Mama Lil's peppers(no substitutions)
Build Your Own Deep Dish Pie (9")
pizzas don't get cut. Serves 2-3. Three toppings included

12'' Deep Dish Pizza(no preorder for dine in please)
The Original (12")
to go pizzas don't get cut unless specifically asked for upon arrival. Serves 4-6. Sausage, pepperoni, caramelized onion (no substitutions)
The Pisano (12")
to go pizzas don't get cut unless specifically asked for upon arrival. Serves 4-6. Sausage, roasted garlic, broccoli (no substitutions)
The Antichrist (12")
to go pizzas don't get cut unless specifically asked for upon arrival. Serves 4-6. Capicola, pineapple. (no substitutions)
The Plethora (12")
to go pizzas don't get cut unless specifically asked for upon arrival. Serves 4-6. Pepperoni, Green Peppers, pepperoncini, Mama Lil's peppers. (No substitutions)
The Tree Hugger (12")
to go pizzas don't get cut unless specifically asked for upon arrival. Serves 4-6. Roasted garlic, mushroom, spinach, artichokes. (no substitutions)
The Bay Area (12")
to go pizzas don't get cut unless specifically asked for upon arrival. Serves 4-6. Chicken, bacon, spinach. (no substitutions)
The Superfan (12")
to go pizzas don't get cut unless specifically asked for upon arrival. Serves 4-6. Pepperoni, sausage, Green Pepper, mushrooms, black olives. (no substitutions)
Mama's Meatball (12")
to go pizzas don't get cut unless specifically asked for upon arrival. Serves 4-6. Meatballs, garlic, ricotta, Mama Lil's peppers. (no substitutions)
Build Your Own Deep Dish Pie (12")
to go pizzas don't get cut unless specifically asked for upon arrival. Serves 4-6. Three toppings included

Salads
Greek Salad Small
Romaine Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Feta, Kalamata olive, and Mediterranean viniagrette
Greek Salad Large
Romaine Lettuce, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Feta, Kalamata olive, and Mediterranean viniagrette
Caesar Salad Small
Romaine, Croutons, Parmesan, Caesar Dressing
Caesar Salad Large
Romaine, Croutons, Parmesan, Caesar Dressing
Garden Salad Small
Romaine, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Green Peppers, and Mushrooms with Balsamic Viniagrette
Garden Salad Large
Romaine, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Green Peppers, and Mushrooms with Balsamic Viniagrettee

Starters
Breadsticks (Copy)
six breadsticks made with our amazing dough, served with Marinara
Side of Ranch Dressing (Copy)
We sold our soul to the devil for this ranch recipe, so we're not giving it away for free!

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+47 photos
Photo credit: google
+46 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I’d rate West of Chicago Pizza Company a solid 5 out of 5 stars — easily one of the best pizza spots in Seattle. The Chicago-style pizza was outstanding: rich flavor, perfectly balanced sauce and cheese, and exactly the kind of deep-dish experience you hope for. Definitely a place I’d go back to and highly recommend to anyone craving authentic Chicago pizza in the Seattle area.
May 2026
Not sure why I haven't review this place yet. Every time I've had their pizza it has been great. The deep dish is everything I could want in that style of pizza. For the first time, yesterday, we had the tavern style thib crust and it was flavor packed. Great food, polite service and the atmosphere feels nice.
March 2026
First time diners and we weren't disappointed. Pizza had flavor and a great crunch. Lots of seating available when we arrived. Fountain sodas are Jones'....mmmm. Haven't had a Jones in yearz.
February 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Tab milktea - 4611 36th Ave SW
Bubble Tea, Coffee & Tea
Northwest Texas Barbecue - across the street from the Y, 4611 36th Ave SW West Seattle 98126 Pickups
Barbecue, Barbeque, Food Stands
Lillie's Passion LLC - 4611 36th Ave SW
Vegetarian

West of Chicago Pizza Company

3770 SW Alaska St, Seattle, WA 98126
(206) 339-3337