Windy City Pie

5918 Phinney Ave N, Seattle
(206) 486-4743

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jessie McLeod

Honestly one of the best pizzas I've ever had. So good! Staff is so friendly, cocktails were great.

Joe Santavicca

Only did pick up.

If you’re looking for tavern style this is it. wow

Craig Mueller

10/10 Coming from a Chicagoan, their thin crust pizza checks all the boxes! Thin, Crispy, full of flavor. Highly recommend a side of giardiniera.

phillip pehrson

Great pie!

Persi Tam

Really tasty deep dish and tavern style pizzas. Ambiance is very Chicago. You can even get Malort shots here!

Matthew Anderson

Some of best pizza in Seattle which is hard to come by. Friendly staff. Great service.

Edward Bottom

Excellent authentic deep dish pizza, high quality salads and an impressive cocktail selection.

Victoria Martinez

They used to have a sister restaurant called Breezy Town pizza in Beacon Hill which is what I was obsessed with. Luckily when they shut down that spot, they still offer their Detroit style sourdough pizza on a few days during the week at Windy City. They also offer two different style Chicago style pizzas in addition to delicious salads. They have games and plenty of seating. TVs and a bar. Its a great chill vibe. They've increased their prices slightly but are transparent that they did it to eliminate the need for tip to offer a living wage to their workers.

Austin Ashley

We got a breezy style pie (a delicious mash up of Chicago style and Detroit style), a beet salad, a couple beers for about $70. We left satisfied and had a slice of pizza leftover. Service charge and tip is built into their price.

The beet salad had great flavors and textures and was well balanced.

The pizza was phenomenal. Plenty of toppings, crispy and stringy cheese, good flavors. Right amount of sauce.

Will definitely be back!

Jay P

Excellent pizza and tasted fresh, will be back to try the thin crust style.
I like how tips have been removed and how the prices have been adjusted appropriately. I prefer this.

Jim D

This place is great! Lived in Chicago for a while and their pizza is an incredible tribute! No tipping/service fees because they pay their staff well, check it out!!

Jared Keith

Excellent pizza, top 5 we’ve had in Seattle. Good cocktails, and pleasantly surprised by a nicer little more elevated wine selection in a pretty casual spot. Really great vibes, cozy atmosphere and the folks working were very welcoming and kind. Will be back often!

Jessica D

We've order from this place a couple times, holding out hope that it will be better than the last time, but it's always incredibly burnt. We ordered the thin crust pepperoni and it was so charred the pepperoni crumbled to dust. Completely inedible. We're from Chicago and really wish this place tasted like real Chicago thin crust. So disappointed.

Angus Bennion

Great pizza!

Joshua McKellar

Incredible pizza. We had a couple tavern styles and they were perfect, just what we wanted. Excellent service. Hope to come back soon!

Loading...