Abby's Legendary Pizza

4804 Tieton Dr, Yakima
(509) 966-1398

Recent Reviews

Tami Davis

No more salad bar! That's why we come here. Unfortunately probably won't be back. I ordered a salad and it's not the same, I'm very sad.

Michael Angelica

Recommended by a friend, got the Abby special. Great pizza, awesome taste!!!! Definitely coming back ??Food: 5/5

tanya smith

It was ok. I thought they could have put more pepperoni. But I really liked the size of their personal pan and price. I recommend, but remember it's pizza and it's not special.

Taylor Madison (Tay Tay)

We were a party of 6, 3 kids & 3 adults. The kiddos ages were from under a year to 4 years old. One of the adults has very strict restrictions on what they can and cannot eat, two of us are vegetarian and one of use eats just about anything! We were each able to order something for ourselves and our children that everyone was happy with! The prices were super fair and the pizza was really, really good. Some of the best pizza I've had since I was a kid I think!

Leon Olson

Ordered online and pizza was ready as scheduled. Prices are a bit high but you get a quality product. Excellent pizza! Deep dish! No regrets. Helpful pleasant staff.


I wouldn't even give 1 star if I didn't have to. I went in to have salad and bread sticks with my Grandson. We didn't want to eat the salads, but we're starving, so we did eat some bread sticks. The salad was brown with dried out carrots, and slimmy cucumbers. We did not eat it cuz it was so off putting. So we told the employee's and they didn't act surprised at all. In fact kinda acted like it was funny. So they gave us a refund for the 2 salad's. I'm so Grossed out that we ate any thing at all. So... I thought I forgot my cell phone, and we went back inside. We caught the guys digging through are salad's and salvaging what they could out of them. Bare in mind we had already been digging through them ourselves looking for anything good to eat They were puttingp back what they thought looked good enough to reserve to some other unexspecting customer.. ??? ? OMGOSH SO GROSS !!!! ISN'T THAT A HEALTH CODE VIOLATION?? If they did it to us they will do it to you. Nasty!!!!!

Darby. Brown B.

Had a very unpleasant experience this evening through Uber. First start Uber driver told us they messed up on something and that he had to wait for a while. When we got our food one pizza was supposed to be at a certain way and it had mushrooms onions everything that we asked not to be on there. We asked for Parmesan and red pepper flakes and there was none of those, and the salad looks like the lettuce sat around for days As did the toppings for the taco pizza. We contacted Uber and they told us to contact Abbys and when we contacted Abbys after a long wait we're told we needed to call back later and talk to the manager. I don't think so. I told them I would just dispute the charge and they said OK. Never again Abbys. We always supported this business but this should've been fixed immediately.

Kathy Lee Burnam

Closing time on their web page is 10pm. I called at 8pm. Was told they can’t deliver because the driver won’t be back for 20 minutes. Assuming it will take 20 minutes to prepare an order I don’t see the issue. Thanks for allowing me to save money?

Kathleen Anderson

The pizza is as good as you can get anywhere, even Chicago. It's not deep dish but thin crust and the crust is better than most. This is the place in Yakima to get pizza. They also offer a fantastically delicious spinach salad, which I highly recommend. I wish I could give it more stars. This is what pepperoni pizza should be.


This pizza is so good!! We have been coming here for years. Thin, delicious crust. Great place to stop for pizza between the Seattle area and the Tri-Cities for sure.

Dave C.

Premium, hearty toppings gracefully blanket a canvas of dough with an almost mathematical precision and beauty. Every bite to your slice seems to deliver a different sensual experience for your tastebuds. The deliciousness of their pizzas transcend space and time to the dimension of gods and their ambrosia. I'm not being hyperbolic here... Abby's Legendary Pizza offers, quite simply, the best pizza in Yakima. Personal favorites include "The Sicilian" and the "Greek Vegetarian." I lean more towards the deep dish crust, but the thin crust is also divine. Thank you, Abby's. Thank you for conjuring pizza fit for gods in your kitchen for us mere mortals of Yakima.

Amanda Schmierer

Whoever wrote best gluten free pizza ever, I feel bad for them because I've had much better in Idaho. It was ok, not great pizza. We stopped while traveling & were hungry so we ate it. Reminded me of Round Table Pizza...90's style Pizza with modern prices. Ok if you are starving.

Melissa Miles

Abby's is a great local pizza shop in Yakima. If you are looking for a place to have a gathering or perhaps a birthday party, this is one of the most affordable places to take your family. A small arcade with some "play til you win' games do not disappoint, and while the prices for the Pizza may appear on the pricier side, the pies are well worth it and less feeds more. Another great gem in the Yakima Valley.

Riggs Rangel

Excellent pizza hands down probably the best pizza in Yakima. Family friendly atmosphere, including a game room for kids, tv screens for sports games. A great choice for a birthday party for a kid or an adult(adult kid?) as they serve alcohol as well. The fried chicken is good, the salads are good. You basically can't go wrong with the menu choice & quality of the available items. This place is wheelchair accessible too. Side note: for whatever reason they don't have ketchup bottles/dispensers, it would be a good idea to bring your own ketchup (I know) & maybe your favorite hot sauce. In any event the pizza is choice quality in my humble opinion, highly recommend the hometown hero!!

Mikhail Dwyer

Clean when I entered. Was only there to apply but the people were very nice, but proffesionally focused. They know how to make anybody WANT to work with them, let alone taste the pizza!! Absolutely reccomend!

Load More