Wishing Well

2709 E Newberry St, Appleton
(920) 734-4472

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

+19 photos
+18 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Had dinner with friends and found a spot to sit right away. Bar was busy and 2 bartender but they also had to play the role of waitress. They did a very good job. Fish were small but hot, french fries were cold, potatoe salad was ok and the coleslaw was good. We ordered appetizers but they came with the dinner instead of beforemaking the table too full to actually enjoy everything.
When you pull into the parking lot you question your decision and when you walk through the door you haven't been reassured -- but sit in a stool and very soon you will see what a great place this is. Great service and food. What did you want afterall??
Took in a Friday fishfry at this small, unique, neighborhood bar/eating place with just a few tables. Casual, informal, friendly, with welcoming locals, good food, informal servers, A place where it feels good to help by cleaning off your own table afterwards...which we did! ? Unfortunately our Old Fashions were not made correctly, which was disappointing.

More Reviews