Cantafio's Buckhorn Steakhouse

Ordered a dinner for two they were out of. Then ordered a different steak for my son. Sent it back the first time cause it was rare when he ordered medium and he could chew it. Sent the new one back as it was all fat and couldn’t chew. Ordered the prime rib and it was cold and had no flavor. Definitely not at all like I remember has change for the worst

Awesome!

2021.....Fish(Perch, bluegill) had very little flavor. Very bland. Prime rib tasted like roast beef and was one of the worst I have had. Very tender, though. Old fashioneds are very good and after dinner ice cream drinks are great, too. The onion ring loaf was excellent, as well.
Edit: 3-29-2025... worst Prime Rib I have ever had, no flavor whatsoever this time and tough and chewy. Food hasn't gotten any better, rib eye my dad had was seriously subpar, mom's chicken was dry and tough. Won't need to come back until it changes ownership.

Went here for the first time tonight. Waitress was terrible. Never checked on how things were. We had to track down a person to send my steak back. It’s a steakhouse that can’t cook steak!! I had to send it back twice. Mind you I ordered it medium well and it was practically mooing not once but twice. Third time I told them to take it off my bill. Soup was cold cream of potato it’s great cold Not! I’ve never been so disappointed with a dinner out. I can make a steak at home better than what we had tonight. I wouldn’t recommend this establishment.

Charming staff, GREAT food, lots of options. Everything was delicious from the prawns to the steak to the roast duck. Yes,I tried everything from my fellow diners plates. We will return and select something different from the menu. Make sure to try the old fashions.

Cantafio’s Buckhorn is hands down my favorite dining spot near Beaver Dam, offering an exceptional experience from start to finish. The service here is consistently top-notch—friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu, ensuring you feel right at home. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, with a homey charm that makes it perfect for a relaxed yet indulgent meal. The rustic yet refined decor complements the warmth of the staff, creating an atmosphere where you can truly unwind.

The NY Strip is an absolute standout. Cooked to perfection, each bite was tender and flavorful, proving that they know exactly how to treat a good cut of meat. The scallops were equally impressive—plump, perfectly fried, and dipped in butter to enhance their natural sweetness. The portion size of the scallops were generous, Cantafio’s Buckhorn strikes a perfect balance between comfort and quality, making it a must-visit for anyone in the area.

Have been going here for quite some time. The food is always good and the people and atmosphere always fun. Order an ice cream after dinner drink...you won't get one any better than here. The absolute best. My tuna steak is always cooked to perfection. Thanks Joe and Bobbi!!

Gold star family owned and operated. Understaffed but the staff is very friendly and hard working!!! Had a small wait for a Friday night, maybe 15 minutes tops even with the place being busy. The garlic cheese curds were very good. Hot, lightly battered and not overly greasy. Asked for prime rib but it was the most popular steak of the day so got a ribeye instead. Almost 2in thick, tender, full of flavor and juicy. My dad got the clam chowder and filet mignon, tender and well cooked. Large baked potato for a side dish. The waitress was extremely friendly, would definitely recommend and return.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Clam Chowder

At the start, siting down the crackers were packaged in food saver sealer bags at 2 crackers in each package which was not done commercially that should have been our clue to leave then. My $36 ribeye steak was pretty sad I've had McDonald's cheeseburgers that thicker and had more flavor then this slab of meat. It was like they took a ribeye steak and cut in 1/4 with a ban saw.The salad had cherry tomatoes that were at the end of their lifespan as far as being edible. My Gf had the 6oz stuffed tenderloin that was maybe the size of a hockey puck and they weren't stuffed everything was on top of the tenderloin. The couple that was with us she was supposed to have an 8oz tenderloin and came out maybe a 4 to 6 oz at best. The drinks were weak and the staff was way under staffed. At best. If I was to give a rating it would be a half star and that's it. You'd be better off goin to Culver's for dinner and saving some $$ and woukd be more satisfied then the dinner was at Buckhorn steakhouse in Beaverdam

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Great food. Great service. Feels like family.

Great food. great service. Highly recommend!

Friendly staff, great food and you're supporting a Gold Star Family!

Food Terrible. Very fishy fries,old oil. Soupy mashed potatoes, chicken sandwich like leather.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 3

What a great meal. We are ever disapointed.

Wheelchair accessibility: Easy access poeple in tbe bar were very cordial

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

First time there. Wonderful service and excellent food.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5