10 Best Irish Pubs near Elm Grove

“Bartenders are attentive and we loved the breaded mushrooms and homemade chips!“

“Hitting my 100th restaurant feels like a milestone worth celebrating somewhere special—and there was no question where that had to be. McKiernan's Irish Pub has been my go-to hole-in-the-wall for a long time, and it still manages to feel like a hidden gem every single visit.

What keeps me coming back? The weekly food and drink specials are always on point—creative, consistent, and priced right. But let’s be honest, the real star for me is the fried chicken. When Dee’s in the kitchen, it somehow hits another level—crispy, flavorful, and exactly what you want every single time.

There’s something rare about a place that nails both quality and heart, and this spot does it effortlessly. It’s incredibly well-run without ever losing that laid-back, welcoming vibe that makes you feel like a regular even on your first visit. You can tell they care—about the food, the experience, and the people walking through the door.

This isn’t just another stop on the list—it’s a place I genuinely hold close. If you walk into McKiernan’s, just know you’re in for a real treat. And for me, there was no better place to mark number 100.“

“Great place to hang out. When you are ready to leave you are a regular at the pub.“

“The only bar I ever won the shake of the Day. It was 58 Dollars on almost everything got two dollar Tuesday. It a West Allis dive bar bartenders are okay Hours are unknown hit or miss it must be an agnostic Irish bar . We don't know the hour, but If Tuesday we are drinking there if they are open“

“Watched English football in a nice atmosphere. The drinks were cheap and the food ok.“

“Awesome food! Awesome staff! Love love love the patio!“

“Hardworking and enjoyable people own and operate this renovated, neighborhood bar-restaurant, JUST West of 124th and North. Good comfort food and great Irish decor.“

“Good food great service! Would definitely go back!“

“Came up with friends for Harley Homecoming weekend. Our buddy picked this place and I am glad he did. It was amazing! Try the Scotch Egg and spring roll. Delicious! Get something that has corned beef in it! The staff were awesome and friendly. We will be back to try more when we are in the area again.“

“Attended tonight to see Rustbucket the band. They are awesome! The sound was excellent in the place as well. We enjoyed our drinks and food was reasonable priced. Our waiter Brad was so great. He was very attentive and very kind with a great sense of humor! “