BaySide Tavern

4160 Main St, Fish Creek
(920) 868-3441

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Cheese Curds Dine in: Yes Takeout: Yes
Bayside Bloody Mary Beer Chaser
Smilen' Bob's Chili Pizza
Cheese Curds with Ranch
Bayside Deluxe Pizza
Bacon Cheeseburger
Sweet Potato Fries
Fish and Chips
Fish and Fries
Fish Sandwich

Menu

Deli Sandwiches and Wraps
Corned Beef Deli Sandwiches and Wraps
Sandwiches served with cheese, crisp lettuce, and tomato.
Roast Beef Deli Sandwiches and Wraps
Sandwiches served with cheese, crisp lettuce, and tomato.
Ham Deli Sandwiches and Wraps
Sandwiches served with cheese, crisp lettuce, and tomato.
Turkey Deli Sandwiches and Wraps
Sandwiches served with cheese, crisp lettuce, and tomato.

Steaks and More
Ribeye Steak
12-oz ribeye topped with mushrooms, onion rings, salad, and a twice-baked potato.
Steak Sandwich
Finest cut of tenderloin, butterflied and grilled the way you like it. Served on a grilled roll with French fries.
Pork Chop Sandwich
6-oz boneless pork chop on a grilled roll. Topped with American cheese and onion rings.

Bayside Favorites
Philly Sandwich
Topped with green peppers, onions, and Monterey jack cheese. Served with potato chips and pickles.
Hot Turkey MJ
A bayside original juicy turkey, Monterey jack cheese, lettuce, and mayonnaise on grilled whole wheat bread. Served with potato chips and pickles.
Chicken Bacon and Swiss
Our grilled chicken fillet plus crisp bacon, swiss cheese, lettuce, and honey dijon.
Grilled Cheese
The classic sandwich with American cheese on grilled white bread.
Pepper Jack Philly
Lean roast beef on a grilled hoagie with green peppers, onions, and pepper jack cheese. Served with potato chips and pickles.
Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato
Crispy bacon. Lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on toasted white bread.
Grilled Cheese, Bacon, and Tomato
Our classic grilled cheese with American cheese, plus crisp bacon, and fresh tomato.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: tripadvisor
+39 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+38 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

I do not typically leave poor reviews however the chili sounds way better on the menu than what shows up to the table - they did not drain the ground beef before adding it to the bowl - someone added way too much chili powder to the ground beef- maybe find a different recipe?

Servers were nice
May 2025
YouTube channel Team IceHole here giving my honest opinion of Bayside Tavern in Fish Creek Wisconsin. The food is amazing and we ordered and in under 5 minutes we had our fresh delicious check out the pictures below. And the prices are very reasonable and very great service. I would recommend them to everyone please come check them out and enjoy some amazing food
April 2025
Amazing cheese curds!! The salad with Ahi tuna was absolutely amazing. Way better than I was expecting from a bar/tavern. The salad itself was good and the tuna was outta this world.

The atmosphere was great too, on the night I went. We were hungry after a long day and left shocked at how good the food was.
April 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Shiny Moon Café - 4164 Main St 2nd Floor
Cafe
Kettle Black Fish Boil - 4158 Main St
Cajun/Creole, Chicken Shop, Hot Dogs, Seafood
Barringer's Restaurant - 1 Spruce St
American, Seafood, Cocktail Bar, Vegetarian

BaySide Tavern

4160 Main St, Fish Creek, WI 54212
(920) 868-3441