Not Licked Yet Frozen Custard
4054 Main St, Fish Creek
(920) 868-2617
Recent Reviews
Sort by
4054 Main St, Fish Creek
(920) 868-2617
Yummy turtle Sunday
Always ✊👅
Dairy free options available too
Banana thing
Dole whip
Feed the ducks
Free your mind
Love this place
Delicious frozen custard and ice cream! They have so many choices!
Pretty average. Not bad but very expensive even for Door County
It's a must stop for ice cream.
Located in Fish Creek near the entrance to Peninsula State Park.
They have outdoor seating, a children's playground and heaters if you visit at night.
I stop here at least once every time I visit Door County. Love me a turtle sundae.
As always, great custard
I ordered a malt and it had lots of flavor and was thick. But my husband ordered a sundae that was already melted by the time we got it on a cold night. It was really overflowing on the sides, his hands were drenched and sticky.
Sundae tasted fine, but the portion size definitely didn't match the price. When the girl handed it to me she said the ice cream is dripping down the sides, and pointed me to the napkins. I wiped the sides of the extremely small container, but the melted ice cream kept drizzling out the side due to the undersized container it was in. I have no complaints towards the staff. They were not rude.
Best frozen custard in Wisconsin! Butter pecan heaven 😋!
Restaurantji Recommends
Wife had a hot cherry sundae and I had a chocolate malt. Both were delicious and they had plenty of choice for seating. Big play area fir the kids
This stop was a highlight of our trip. The long line moves fast. There’s a playground for kids, lots of seating, and a little duck pond. The ice cream was amazingly delicious. 10/10 recommend!
Great custard! Servings are huge! Pretty park and pond to walk around while eating.
Great custard as usual. I had a great strawberry concrete! Lots of strawberries!
Classic Door County; who knew there were so many ways to enjoy frozen custard. Sticky goodness regardless of one’s age. Gnome secrets to locals and visitors.
Loading...