Blue Heaven Ice Cream

next to the Shell gas station, 105 W Main St, Fontana-On-Geneva Lake
(262) 394-5177

Recent Reviews

Sort by
George Ortiz

Drove 20+ miles for a soggy waffle cone with an extremely sugary ice cream cone. The rainbow sherbet ice cream is no better than the multi-color gallon ice cream from a large box grocery chair store. Very disappointed.

Brooke Larson

Such a cute place, yummy ice cream. Some tables and chairs outside. Order at the window or inside when it’s slow

Moe Amer

Fabulous Ice Cream

Altay Ozyavas

The ice cream is okay but the portions are small for the price.

David

Wonderful ice cream!

Erika & Tyler Schmitz

My husband and I recently hired the Blue Heaven team for dessert at our wedding in Fontana. We aren't big cake people and wanted to do something a little different and fun! The owner, John, was super organized leading up to the event and even had us come into the shop for a tasting to pick out flavors and toppings which we loved!! A nice bonus was that they had a few non-dairy ice cream flavors and sorbet options to choose from for guests that might have dietary restrictions. We got a ton of compliments from our guests on the ice cream and the cute cart!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gloria Sosa

Super tasty ice creams ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tammy Lynn Marie

Adorable, yummy and super clean🍦

Callaghan Cavanaugh

the blue ice cream is awesome!! so high quality and good! this is not the business’s fault but when i was there there was a little blond boy kicking the sign and yelling, quite the show. watch out for the kids here!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alex P

The ice cream is good.

Wheelchair accessibility: Not wheelchair accessible. Bummer.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Jody Schuenke

Wonderful icecream flavors, beautiful little shop, very clean. Would recommend you give it a try!! Prices decent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cody Boettcher

Nice little shop, liked every ice cream everyday we had it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hon Solo

So we were here last night before closing. As we were eating, the workers began cleaning up and locked the door to close. A couple minutes later a teenager walked up with his little sister excited to get some ice cream only to find that the place was closed. As they turned their back to leave, one of the workers opened the door and advised the two that they were closed, but they would still serve them as they welcomed the two in. Another gentleman walked up and they served him too as well. When I witnessed this, I was blown away just how nice the workers there were. They didn’t have to open their doors back up as it was past their business hours, but they did just because they are selfless and willing to be inconvenienced just to make someone else’s day. So not only was their ice cream delicious, their service was impeccable. It was awesome to see such generosity from two teenage workers that seems to be less common these days. Thank you for the wonderful experience!

Kat Froeber

Yummy ice cream. Any ice cream you can imagine.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Barbara McMahon

The ice cream was yummy! My Mom (100!), my husband and I had a variety of ice cream: praline pecan, loaded Oreo, raspberry, vanilla with hot fudge, raspberry lemon Italian ice, moose tracks! The outside seating is pleasant, umbrellas on the tables and comfy chairs!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...