Black Otter Supper Club

503 S Nash St, Hortonville
(920) 779-6975

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Tenderloin and Deep-Fried Lobster Tail and Homemade Potato Skins
Extreme Prime Rib King Crab Legs Porterhouse Steak Dinner
Tenderloin and Cajun Shrimp Scampi
Ribeye and Deep Fried Scallops
Salad with Home Made Croutons
Tenderloin and Potato Wedges
Tenderloin Steak and Perch
All You Can Eat White Fish
Appetizing Cajun Chicken
Cajun Chicken with Bacon

Menu

Appetizers
Deep-Fried Mushrooms
Mozzarella Sticks
Onion Rings
Cheese Curds
Broccoli Cheddar Bites
Hot Wings Inferno
Jalapeno Poppers
Mixed Basket
Onion rings, cheese curds, mushrooms, mozzarella sticks, and French fries.
Tavern Mix
Chicken strips, French fries, cheese curds, and onion rings.
Cajun Seasoned Skins
Shrimp Cocktail

Seafood Favorites
Lake Perch from Cool
Lake waters, lightly breaded, and deep-fried.
Deep-fried Haddock
A highly prized and excellent flavored fish.
Broiled Haddock
Broiled to perfection in butter.
Cajun Broiled Haddock
An excellent choice.
Walleye Pike
A delicious freshwater fish lightly breaded.
Cajun Broiled Pike
Heat up those taste buds.
Fantail Shrimp
Deep-fried and served with cocktail sauce.
Peel & Eat Shrimp
One pound served hot or cold.
Fresh Broiled Shrimp
A real tasty treat.
Jumbo Shrimp
Hand-breaded.
Cajun Shrimp Scampi
A mouth-watering delight.
Deep-Fried Scallops
Tender morsels from the sea.
Blue Gill
Seafood Platter
A tempting variety of deep-fried treasures lake perch, walleye pike haddock, bluegill, shrimp, and scallops.

Other White Meat
Cajun Chicken Breasts
Two broiled chicken breasts, topped with mozzarella cheese, bacon pieces, and Cajun seasoning.
Broiled Chicken Breasts
Two skinless, boneless chicken breasts, tender and juicy.
Ham Steak (2 lb)
Thick bone-in country cut, broiled to perfection.
Broiled Pork Chops
Two centers cut chops.

Our Own Baby Back Bbq Ribs
Our Own Baby Back BBQ Ribs
Tender pork ribs in a Memphis mesquite sweet-n-spicy mouth-watering sauce.

For the Lighter Appetite
Perch (1/2)
Pike (1/2)
Fantail Shrimp (1/2)
Broiled Shrimp (1/2)
Broiled Haddock (1/2)
Deep-Fried Haddock (1/2)
One Chicken Breast (Broiled)
One Pork Chop (Broiled)
Ham (1/2)

Kids Menu
Hot Dog
Served with French fries. .
Chicken Strips
Served with French fries. .
Macaroni & Cheese Bites
Served with French fries. .
Grilled Cheese
Served with French fries. .
Haddock Bites with Salad Bar
Served with French fries. .

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: foursquare
Photo credit: facebook
+50 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+49 photos
Add a photo

Order Online

Recent Reviews

We went there for our 51st Anniversary and wanted a relaxed dinner. We felt very rushed during the meal. When we wanted an after dinner drink they told us we have to go to the bar if we wanted the drink because they needed our table. We were at the table less then 35 minutes.
Salad bar was great along with friendly staff. Steaks were cooked perfectly but very salty.
June 2026
First time coming here, but it wont be the last. Very small parking lot, so be prepared to park on the street. Went on a Wed, and had no wait. Waitress was great! Food orders taken quickly,and table was ready shortly after that. Salad bar (with bartenders) had a great selection, all items tasted fresh. Main courses were delicious. My group had 3 different types of steak, and 2 different types of fish, plus 4 different types of potato. All was spot on perfectly cooked and seasoned....
May 2026
Visiting from NC and dined here with relatives. OMG, this place is off the charts! Everything was superb from start to finish. They have a salad bar to die for. Lettuce, spinach, cole slaw, cottage cheese, and more. Several toppings, a lot of vegetables, cheeses, fruit, and it went on and on. They also had chicken soup and clam chowder; I had both. The chicken soup was especially good. After all of that, it was time for dinner. I had the angus rib eye, and others had prime rib,...
May 2026

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Otter Creek Sports Bar & Grill - 110 W Main St
American, Pizza, Bar, Pet Friendly
Alley Cat Coffeehouse - 213 W Main St
Cafe, Coffee & Tea
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill - 241 E Main St
Fast Food, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Burgers

Black Otter Supper Club

503 S Nash St, Hortonville, WI 54944
(920) 779-6975