Elsie Mae's Sweet Shop
1101 E Brady St, Milwaukee
(262) 914-9198
Menu
Photos
+35 photos
+34 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Amazing pies! I love their blueberry banana cream pie. The French silk is the best French silk pie I have ever had. The crust is what makes all their pies stand out. They also have very good customer service.
We love these pies. We were getting them from the harbor market on weekends when the storefront closed but I also like the little red pie wagon. It’s such a cute concept. The pies are absolutely delicious. My favorite is the mermaid pie which I never would have tried on my own but it’s amazing.
The name and photos in this listing are misleading. There is no pie shop here, but a grocery store called Tenuta's that carries a few varieties of Elsie Mae's pies (some fresh, some frozen). The pie I had (strawberry rhubarb, a staff favorite) was very good, but selection was very limited. The owner of this listing might consider changing it to \\\"Elsie Mae's at Tenuta's\\\" and removing pics of a storefront that doesn't exist.
You May Also Like
Peter Sciortino Bakery - 1101 E Brady St
![]()
Bakery, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian
Hosed On Brady - 1689 N Franklin Pl
![]()
Pubs, Bar
Dryhootch Coffeehouse - 1030 E Brady St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee