Potbelly
899 W Main St, Lake Geneva
(262) 248-4663
Customers' Favorites
Avo Turkey
Sandwich
Avocado
Soup
Featured items
Turkey Breast
Hand-sliced turkey breast, swiss
Italian
Salami, old-world capicola, pepperoni, mortadella, provolone
A Wreck®
A meaty fan favorite! Turkey breast, hickory smoked ham, Angus roast beef, salami, swiss
Mediterranean
All-natural grilled chicken, feta, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, cucumbers, and our signature hot pepper hummus
Avo Turkey
Hand-sliced turkey breast, swiss, fresh-sliced avocado, cucumbers
Mama's Meatball
Homestyle beef + pork meatballs smothered in marinara sauce, provolone, Italian seasoning
Chicken Club
All-natural grilled chicken, applewood smoked bacon, cheddar
Skinny Sandwich + Cup of Soup
Pair two of your favorites: a skinny sandwich with a cup of mac & cheese, chili or soup
Chocolate Shake
Made with hand-dipped ice cream
OREO® Cookie Shake
Made with hand-dipped ice cream. OREO is a trademark of Mondelez International group, used under license.
Sandwiches
A Wreck®
A meaty fan favorite! Turkey breast, hickory smoked ham, Angus roast beef, salami, swiss
Chicken Club
All-natural grilled chicken, applewood smoked bacon, cheddar
Mama's Meatball
Homestyle beef + pork meatballs smothered in marinara sauce, provolone, Italian seasoning
Turkey Breast
Hand-sliced turkey breast, swiss
Mediterranean
All-natural grilled chicken, feta, artichoke hearts, roasted red peppers, cucumbers, and our signature hot pepper hummus
Grilled Chicken
All-natural grilled chicken, cheddar
Avo Turkey
Hand-sliced turkey breast, swiss, fresh-sliced avocado, cucumbers
Pizza Melt
Pepperoni, old-world capicola, crumbled meatball, smothered in marinara sauce, provolone, Italian seasoning, mushrooms (where available)
Smoked Ham
Hickory smoked ham, swiss
BLTA
Applewood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, fresh-sliced avocado
Italian
Salami, old-world capicola, pepperoni, mortadella, provolone
Roast Beef
Angus roast beef, provolone
Tuna Salad
100% albacore tuna salad, swiss
Chicken Salad
Chicken salad, provolone
Steakhouse Beef
Angus roast beef, crumbled blue cheese, provolone, horseradish aioli
Veggie Melt
Fresh-sliced avocado, swiss, cheddar, provolone, mushrooms (where available)
Ring of Fire
All-natural grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, cheddar, our signature hot pepper ranch and Yellowbird® ghost pepper hot sauce
Salads
Farmhouse Salad
All-natural grilled chicken breast, bacon (where available), crumbled blue cheese, hard-boiled egg, cucumber, tomatoes, served on a bed of field greens, with creamy buttermilk ranch
Apple Walnut Salad
All-natural grilled chicken breast, crumbled blue cheese, grapes, apples, dried cranberries, candied walnuts, served on a bed of field greens, with balsamic vinaigrette
Powerhouse Salad
All-natural grilled chicken breast, fresh-sliced avocado, hummus, hard-boiled egg, cucumber, tomatoes, served on a bed of field greens, with fat free vinaigrette
Chicken Salad Salad
Chicken salad, provolone, dried cranberries, cucumbers, tomatoes, field greens, balsamic vinaigrette
Pick-your-Pair
Skinny Sandwich + Cup of Soup
Pair two of your favorites: a skinny sandwich with a cup of mac & cheese, chili or soup
Half Salad + Cup of Soup
Pair two of your favorites: a half salad with a cup of mac & cheese, chili or soup
Skinny Sandwich + Half Salad
Pair two of your favorites: a skinny sandwich with a half salad
Chips + Sides
Zapp's Salt & Vinegar Chips
Zapp's Mesquite Bar-B-Que Chips
Potbelly Whole Pickle
Zapp's Regular Chips
Zapp's Hotter 'N Hot Jalapeño Chips
Chips + Drink
Make it a Meal Deal! Choose any chips and a drink.
Chips + Shake
Make it a Meal Deal! Choose any chips and a shake.
Zapp's VooDoo Regular Chips
Baked Lay's
Zapp's VooDoo Heat Chips
Utz Cheese Curls
Hot Peppers Jar
Our famous giardiniera hot peppers, ready to spice up your kitchen at home. A perfect gift, too.
Cookies + Shakes
OREO® Cookie Shake
Made with hand-dipped ice cream. OREO is a trademark of Mondelez International group, used under license.
Sugar Cookie
Baked fresh daily
Chocolate Brownie Cookie
Baked fresh daily
Chocolate Shake
Made with hand-dipped ice cream
Dream Bar
Rich, chocolatey oatmeal bar with sweet caramel
Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie
A Potbelly favorite! Freshly baked oatmeal chocolate chip cookie
Vanilla Shake
Made with hand-dipped ice cream
Bag of Mini Cookies
Dozen mini oatmeal chocolate chip cookies
Strawberry Shake
Made with hand-dipped ice cream
Cold Brew Shake
Cold-brewed Arabica coffee and hand-dipped vanilla ice cream. Shake and wake!
Apple Caramel Cookie
Deliciously sweet apple baked into a soft blonde cookie with hints of caramel
Drinks
Diet Coke
20 oz. Bottle
Sprite
20 oz. Bottle
Arizona Tea
16 oz. Bottle
Powerade Mountain Berry Blast
20 oz. Bottle
Coke Zero Sugar
20 oz. Bottle
Nantucket Nectars Lemonade
16 oz. Bottle
Cherry Coke
20 oz. Bottle
Bottled Water
16 oz. / 25 oz. Bottle
Vitamin Water XXX Acai Blue Pom
20 oz. Bottle
Crush
12 oz. Bottle
IBC Root Beer
12 oz. Bottle
IBC Cream Soda
12 oz. Bottle
Coke
20 oz. Bottle
San Pellegrino Blood Orange
11.15 oz Can
Vitamin Water Squeezed Lemonade
20 oz. Bottle
San Pellegrino
16.9 oz. Bottle
Smartwater
20 oz. Bottle
Gold Peak Sweet Tea
18.5 oz. Bottle
Gold Peak Green Tea
18.5 oz. Bottle
Nantucket Nectars Orange Mango
16 oz. Bottle
Photos
+39 photos
+38 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I had a wonderful experience at Potbelly's, where the food was fresh, flavorful, and delicious, especially their signature sandwich and fresh salad. The staff was incredibly friendly, helpful, and attentive, making the visit even more enjoyable. Highly recommend for a quick, satisfying meal with great service!
February 2025
The food wasn't bad, but it was not good enough to justify the price and the wait time, which was longer than it took to finish my food. The Service was very poor, which is understandable because it seems like it is a very stressful job on their end, but the service was nonetheless bad. It seemed like several of the employees didn't really know what they were doing and in addition to taking a very long time my family and I had to correct several mistakes with our order....
February 2025
You May Also Like
Inspired - 883 W Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee, Pet Friendly
Cold Stone Creamery - 859 W Main St
![]()
Ice Cream Shop, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Custom Cakes, Cupcakes, Ice Cream
Great Eggs - 220 Cook St
![]()
Breakfast, Juice Bar & Smoothies, Coffee & Tea, Pet Friendly
The staff at this location were not on their game that day. We waited to order even though no one was in front of us. No one was watching the toaster and one of the sandwiches almost ended up on the floor. The person who helped us with toppings acted...