Bagels Forever

2947 University Ave, Madison
(608) 231-2427

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Fresh Locs with Bagel and Cream Cheese Capers Came Later

Cream Cheese Chocolate Chip Bagels

Everything Bagels Tomato Basil

Egg Cheese & Turkey Pastrami

Turkey Club Bagel Sandwich

Turkey and Cheese Bagels

Peanut Butter and Jelly

Pepperoni Pizza Bagel

Bagel & Cream Cheese

Cream Cheese Bagels

Photos

+42 photos

+41 photos

Add a photo

Order Online

Postmates

Recent Reviews

The best bagel shop in town!! They have such delightful and affordable bagels with all kinds of fillings. My husband and I love their Lox and their breakfast sandwiches - egg, cheese and honey glazed ham. 😋 we come here every other weekend. It’s always packed with lots of people but they move pretty quick. I also simply love their EGG BAGELS and chocolate chip bagels!!!

November 2025

This is a local go to, and I love the branding/atmosphere-- it feels like you're stepping back into the 80s or 90s. I recommend the salt bagel with Lox! Really well priced, the perfect bagel size too. When it's busy you need to take a number and it's best to right down big orders on the clipboards.

October 2025

We’ve lived in Madison for 8yrs and never stopped here until today. What a mistake - we should have come on day 1! We ordered a dozen bagels (13 here), a lox sandwich, and a sausage egg n cheese sandwich = $19. And the sandwiches were positively delicious. I made some customizations to the lox sandwich and the girl taking our order was SO patient and friendly. We will absolutely be back! Love that they open early too. And there’s a good amount of parking. This was such a great...

October 2025

More Reviews

Restaurants in Madison, WI

Bagels Forever

Customers' Favorites

Menu

Photos

Order Online

Recent Reviews

You May Also Like

Bagels Forever