Walked in and everyone stared at us like we were aliens. Very different clientele than what I'm used to. We just turned around and went back to Chiefs Bar.
Atmosphere: 1
Jim Packard
of course I recommend dutchmill , if you know how to respect people and just have a good night out. you'll find in time they become family/ friends
Monica S.
Waited 40 minutes, waist of my money , the pizza was so hard when you try to get a slice everything fell off of it , I saw the lady picking her but it was si discussing, I would never eat it again even if it was free I'm so disappointed please read my review , they should close this place down Garbage , I left you guys a little picture go see for yourself
Stacie Clark
The grilled chicken here is better than I've had in a while! Toasted bun with a custom rub. Everyone loved the fish fry too. It had classic Midwest dive bar vibes.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
C Mcdonnell
We love it. Me & my Pop's. Out of edgerton, we plan a stop at Dutch Mill whenever we're in Madison. In addition, we make our Dutch Mill a destination for pool tournaments. Great food. People are our type of peeps. Welcoming & fun.They are the whole B.O.W. (ball of wax)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kaleigh Spencer
Cash only. Good little hole in the wall. Very welcoming staff and patrons.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Creamy Goodness
It's not good. You'll pay as much for drinks here as you do at bars on the UW campus. Bartenders are more interested in chatting with their friends than in serving drinks to the generally small number of patrons. When service does happen, it's rude. Non-regulars are made to feel like they shouldn't be there. Spend your beer money somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Mary O'D
Went on a recent Friday around 4. About 8-10 customers were there. I nudged my first empty glass forward...and waited. Waited some more. Then my husband did the same. And we waited. A second bartender (I think?) had come in. The two stood behind one end of the bar chatting. We waited some more. The two didn't seem to look up/around even once. We waited well over 15 minutes and left.
Has a pool table. Has a slot machines, Went with some regulars for karaoke (even though that's not really my thing) had a good time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
O.D. Patton III
Great ownership and staff. Very friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Sherri Hatfield
Love this place. The service is always good. The folks are nice. The only negative is the karaoke is too loud, its a small bar and there is no need to have it so loud that you cant have a conversation or the noise blows you off your seat. Other than that, we always have a great time.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Michael Schaller
I love this place but let's be realistic it has its drawbacks but the bartenders work their butts off and they do a great job in a tough situation.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
melody robbins
Old school bar, has been around for years. Bartenders we great.Great little dive
Great place for lunch and pool.
Walked in and everyone stared at us like we were aliens. Very different clientele than what I'm used to. We just turned around and went back to Chiefs Bar.
Atmosphere: 1
of course I recommend dutchmill , if you know how to respect people and just have a good night out. you'll find in time they become family/ friends
Waited 40 minutes, waist of my money , the pizza was so hard when you try to get a slice everything fell off of it , I saw the lady picking her but it was si discussing, I would never eat it again even if it was free I'm so disappointed please read my review , they should close this place down Garbage , I left you guys a little picture go see for yourself
The grilled chicken here is better than I've had in a while! Toasted bun with a custom rub. Everyone loved the fish fry too. It had classic Midwest dive bar vibes.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We love it. Me & my Pop's. Out of edgerton, we plan a stop at Dutch Mill whenever we're in Madison. In addition, we make our Dutch Mill a destination for pool tournaments. Great food. People are our type of peeps. Welcoming & fun.They are the whole B.O.W. (ball of wax)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Cash only. Good little hole in the wall. Very welcoming staff and patrons.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
It's not good. You'll pay as much for drinks here as you do at bars on the UW campus. Bartenders are more interested in chatting with their friends than in serving drinks to the generally small number of patrons. When service does happen, it's rude. Non-regulars are made to feel like they shouldn't be there. Spend your beer money somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Went on a recent Friday around 4. About 8-10 customers were there. I nudged my first empty glass forward...and waited. Waited some more. Then my husband did the same. And we waited. A second bartender (I think?) had come in. The two stood behind one end of the bar chatting. We waited some more. The two didn't seem to look up/around even once. We waited well over 15 minutes and left.
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 1
Steph does a great job!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Has a pool table. Has a slot machines, Went with some regulars for karaoke (even though that's not really my thing) had a good time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great ownership and staff. Very friendly!
Atmosphere: 5
Love this place. The service is always good. The folks are nice. The only negative is the karaoke is too loud, its a small bar and there is no need to have it so loud that you cant have a conversation or the noise blows you off your seat. Other than that, we always have a great time.
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
I love this place but let's be realistic it has its drawbacks but the bartenders work their butts off and they do a great job in a tough situation.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 3
Old school bar, has been around for years. Bartenders we great.Great little dive
Atmosphere: 5