I decided to give GlassNickel a try again, ordered a pizza and wings and this time wasn't like the last, it's was perfect, Bravo Glass Nickel!!
Abiztic
They offer gluten-free pizza which I appreciate. I eat here often and I don't believe I have ever gotten sick from their pizza which is saying quite a bit since I have celiac disease and need to worry about cross contamination. I wish the gluten-free crust was better - it is very thin and often quite hard. However, that's pretty typical of gluten-free pizza crust just about anywhere you go. Everything else about their pizza is perfect.Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeremy Schafer
The food was absolutely delicious, the pizza was hot when delivered and great service. Will definitely eat there again..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mo T
Best pizza I’ve ever had . The veggie pizza is my fav
Will Schiell
Good place for dinner. Pizza was very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carol Dvorak
The best pizza around in my opinion, especially the Fetalicious! Service is great, atmosphere is great. I love that their table tops are covered with nickels under glass. I frequently get take outs there. Their garden salad (I ask for small but get a big serving) is fresh and crisp and loaded with veggies like cucumbers, cherry tomatoes, shredded carrots, onions, etc for a very reasonable price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeff Wagner
Great customer service, A++ quality Pizza, sauce etc. Our number one pizza joint for Madison/Monona.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jitish N.
The Glass nickel pizza restaurant was very nice as we tried many varieties of thin crust and all were nice.
Tina H.
I have had a 75% success rate with my orders being correct here, but the pizza is really good, order comes out on time, and the appetizers not bad so I keep coming back. Tried a new pizza for Pi Day and tried the Chicky Chicky Parm Parm. Wanted it to be thin crust but it came out regular. Oh well, maybe next time it will be correct. Good amount of sauce and the chicken fried up nicely on the cheesy topping. I usually order The Carnivore --that is a top notch pizza. And the Mac and Cheese Pizza isn't bad either but I don't come here for that one. The mac and cheese bites I also tried were good, but not my top choice (the ravioli bites are better). Overall, I will keep coming because I love their pizza sauce, they use good ingredients, and the staff is friendly.
Patrick Burke
This was by far the best pizza we have had in a long time. We live in Sheboygan. We will be back.
Worst pizza I ever had. Soggy, greasy, horrible flavor.
Food: 1
Michael Myers (Cucuy)
I believe Glass Nickel is the best pizza in Madison. Service is great, great atmosphere. I have never had a wrong order, whether it be there or delivery.
I used a 50% credit last night for a recent disappointing pizza order. I was denied a full refund on my credit card, even though I told the manager that my patronage was over. Several times, for past problematic orders, I didn't bother with the hassle of asking for my money back, or even a store credit. I told him that I've been a customer for a VERY long time (he was not grateful, nor apologetic), and have seen the quality of their pizza go downhill, although, to be fair, at times it could be hit or miss. For a while now there's been noticeable, continual skimping on topping ingredients - this from the most expensive place in town. I doubt customers are fooled by the spread out, diced, not sliced, mushrooms, nor are accepting of toppings missing from inches off the edge. The finale - the following is what I got yesterday, for my very last pie, which was supposed to be a 10" standard thin crust: Flat and floppy 'cracker crust thin', burnt crust, and excessively doughy, thick edges, a couple of sloppy, disheveled slices. Showed up luke warm. The delivery person was very nice - they always are, but he couldn't find me. Approx. an hour and 20-minute wait for another disappointing food delivery. I've given GNP innumerable chances. I think the only real difference with Glass Nickel pizza is that they have a very flavorful sauce and use multiple cheeses in their recipe, which kept me coming back... but not anymore. Also, I didn't appreciate my last review being deleted. By the way, coincidental or not, I got violently ill hours after eating the pizza, which has never happened in my long lifetime of pizza consumption. Maybe this was GNP's payback for my permanent rejection! I probably should have used a different name and address when ordering! The photos are from last night's order and the one, week's prior to that: Left photo: Two or more inches at the edge are topping free. The other slices from yesterday's order reflect my description above.
I decided to give GlassNickel a try again, ordered a pizza and wings and this time wasn't like the last, it's was perfect, Bravo Glass Nickel!!
They offer gluten-free pizza which I appreciate. I eat here often and I don't believe I have ever gotten sick from their pizza which is saying quite a bit since I have celiac disease and need to worry about cross contamination. I wish the gluten-free crust was better - it is very thin and often quite hard. However, that's pretty typical of gluten-free pizza crust just about anywhere you go. Everything else about their pizza is perfect.Dietary restrictions: Gluten-free options
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was absolutely delicious, the pizza was hot when delivered and great service. Will definitely eat there again..
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza I’ve ever had . The veggie pizza is my fav
Good place for dinner. Pizza was very good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pizza around in my opinion, especially the Fetalicious! Service is great, atmosphere is great. I love that their table tops are covered with nickels under glass. I frequently get take outs there. Their garden salad (I ask for small but get a big serving) is fresh and crisp and loaded with veggies like cucumbers, cherry tomatoes, shredded carrots, onions, etc for a very reasonable price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great customer service, A++ quality Pizza, sauce etc. Our number one pizza joint for Madison/Monona.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The Glass nickel pizza restaurant was very nice as we tried many varieties of thin crust and all were nice.
I have had a 75% success rate with my orders being correct here, but the pizza is really good, order comes out on time, and the appetizers not bad so I keep coming back. Tried a new pizza for Pi Day and tried the Chicky Chicky Parm Parm. Wanted it to be thin crust but it came out regular. Oh well, maybe next time it will be correct. Good amount of sauce and the chicken fried up nicely on the cheesy topping. I usually order The Carnivore --that is a top notch pizza. And the Mac and Cheese Pizza isn't bad either but I don't come here for that one. The mac and cheese bites I also tried were good, but not my top choice (the ravioli bites are better). Overall, I will keep coming because I love their pizza sauce, they use good ingredients, and the staff is friendly.
This was by far the best pizza we have had in a long time. We live in Sheboygan. We will be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread Sticks
Restaurantji Recommends
They were very
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really enjoyed the pizza and food. Service was great as well. Was a nice place to enjoy a meal overall. Five stars for me !
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Bread Sticks, Cardiac Arrest, Cheese Bread
Worst pizza I ever had. Soggy, greasy, horrible flavor.
Food: 1
I believe Glass Nickel is the best pizza in Madison. Service is great, great atmosphere. I have never had a wrong order, whether it be there or delivery.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fetalicious Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Cheese Bread, Fetalicious
I used a 50% credit last night for a recent disappointing pizza order. I was denied a full refund on my credit card, even though I told the manager that my patronage was over. Several times, for past problematic orders, I didn't bother with the hassle of asking for my money back, or even a store credit. I told him that I've been a customer for a VERY long time (he was not grateful, nor apologetic), and have seen the quality of their pizza go downhill, although, to be fair, at times it could be hit or miss. For a while now there's been noticeable, continual skimping on topping ingredients - this from the most expensive place in town. I doubt customers are fooled by the spread out, diced, not sliced, mushrooms, nor are accepting of toppings missing from inches off the edge. The finale - the following is what I got yesterday, for my very last pie, which was supposed to be a 10" standard thin crust: Flat and floppy 'cracker crust thin', burnt crust, and excessively doughy, thick edges, a couple of sloppy, disheveled slices. Showed up luke warm. The delivery person was very nice - they always are, but he couldn't find me. Approx. an hour and 20-minute wait for another disappointing food delivery. I've given GNP innumerable chances. I think the only real difference with Glass Nickel pizza is that they have a very flavorful sauce and use multiple cheeses in their recipe, which kept me coming back... but not anymore. Also, I didn't appreciate my last review being deleted. By the way, coincidental or not, I got violently ill hours after eating the pizza, which has never happened in my long lifetime of pizza consumption. Maybe this was GNP's payback for my permanent rejection! I probably should have used a different name and address when ordering! The photos are from last night's order and the one, week's prior to that: Left photo: Two or more inches at the edge are topping free. The other slices from yesterday's order reflect my description above.