The bagels are stale. There is no public bathroom - not worth the money at all.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 3
Scott Slavik
I've been a big fan of this place in the past. But today ordered 4 bagels toasted w cream cheese and got 4 burnt bagels upon pick up. Very disappointed. 😞 Make sure to double check your pick up orders before leaving so you don't spend $30 on burnt bagels.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
naomi w
Please bring back olive cream cheese
K McD
Waited 40 minutes for 2 bagels.
Service: 1
Luan Estrada Gomez
The food is delicious and I’ve never had a bad service experience. The only thing that has had me hesitant to comeback is the wait time. Last time we waited an hour for our bagels and once we finally got them they all had the wrong type of bagel. We understood they were busy so they might have not had the specific bagel we wanted but it would have been nice if they communicated that. The bagels were still good though and the pickle they add on the side is my favorite.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
Kristin Preisler
Four years ago I was treated very unkindly by the owner and decided not to return. Any idea if Gotham is under the same management as 2020?
Vince McManus
The vegan scallion cream cheese was incredibly flavorful on the everything bagel! Good for vegans!
Caroline Hughes
It's time for this place to close.
Nick VandenLangenberg
They have the best bagel in Madison, hands down. However, it does take a long time to get a single bagel with cream cheese. I really like the product, but I don't go very often because of how long it usually takes to prepare orders.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Catsmeow
the food was decent. pricey, but expected for downtown. the staff is friendly ect. the boss/owner is the issue. not trying to slander/drive away customers. advising to watch out for little man big ego, or get screamed at for asking simple questions like wait time. would recommend maybe, if the management of the business was a little more professional and went to some behavioral therapy.
Definitely the best bagels in the area. That said, it is very overpriced and the service is so slow you should probably stop to eat before you order.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
James K
Ham, egg and gouda cheese on everything bagel hit spot.
Food: 5
Cody Neuburg
So good and have it all they really do
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Gianni Artisensi-Skime
This is a 12.67/10 swimming past any other bagel shop near lake Mendota.Gotham bagels is very deceiving name I was expecting emo bagels that had piercings . Such an electric atmosphere filled with the sweet smell of fall and salamander. I like the fact that I wasn’t looked at weird for wearing no shoes I have an amputation on my right big toe so I was a little nervous, but the place felt like home. I got the number 12 with only the bagel part. It was so good I highly recommend the number 12!! I will be stopping by more often consider yourself blessed you have earned a knew loyal customer!! I love Gotham bagels!!!
The bagels are stale. There is no public bathroom - not worth the money at all.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 3
I've been a big fan of this place in the past. But today ordered 4 bagels toasted w cream cheese and got 4 burnt bagels upon pick up. Very disappointed. 😞 Make sure to double check your pick up orders before leaving so you don't spend $30 on burnt bagels.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Please bring back olive cream cheese
Waited 40 minutes for 2 bagels.
Service: 1
The food is delicious and I’ve never had a bad service experience. The only thing that has had me hesitant to comeback is the wait time. Last time we waited an hour for our bagels and once we finally got them they all had the wrong type of bagel. We understood they were busy so they might have not had the specific bagel we wanted but it would have been nice if they communicated that. The bagels were still good though and the pickle they add on the side is my favorite.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3
Four years ago I was treated very unkindly by the owner and decided not to return. Any idea if Gotham is under the same management as 2020?
The vegan scallion cream cheese was incredibly flavorful on the everything bagel! Good for vegans!
It's time for this place to close.
They have the best bagel in Madison, hands down.
However, it does take a long time to get a single bagel with cream cheese. I really like the product, but I don't go very often because of how long it usually takes to prepare orders.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
the food was decent. pricey, but expected for downtown. the staff is friendly ect. the boss/owner is the issue. not trying to slander/drive away customers. advising to watch out for little man big ego, or get screamed at for asking simple questions like wait time. would recommend maybe, if the management of the business was a little more professional and went to some behavioral therapy.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Restaurantji Recommends
Hands down the best bagels in Madison.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Definitely the best bagels in the area. That said, it is very overpriced and the service is so slow you should probably stop to eat before you order.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Ham, egg and gouda cheese on everything bagel hit spot.
Food: 5
So good and have it all they really do
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
This is a 12.67/10 swimming past any other bagel shop near lake Mendota.Gotham bagels is very deceiving name I was expecting emo bagels that had piercings . Such an electric atmosphere filled with the sweet smell of fall and salamander. I like the fact that I wasn’t looked at weird for wearing no shoes I have an amputation on my right big toe so I was a little nervous, but the place felt like home. I got the number 12 with only the bagel part. It was so good I highly recommend the number 12!! I will be stopping by more often consider yourself blessed you have earned a knew loyal customer!! I love Gotham bagels!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...