Johnny Delmonico's Steakhouse

130 S Pinckney St, Madison
(608) 230-5800

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

80 over Priced Steak Lacking Flavor
Filet Mignon and Mashed Potatoes
House-Cut Fries & Truffle Aioli
Miso Glazed Chilean Sea Bass
Wisconsin Macaroni & Cheese
Cheesecake with Cherries
Dry Aged New York Strip
Garlic Mashed Potatoes
Baked French Onion Soup
Creamy Lobster Bisque

Menu

Food Fight Gift Cards
$25 Gift Card
Food Fight is a locally-owned restaurant group with a diverse roster of 19 restaurants, ranging from '50s diner to upscale Italian. Gift cards can be redeemed at all of our restaurants for dine-in visits or call-in carryout orders, and they never expire.
$50 Gift Card
Food Fight is a locally-owned restaurant group with a diverse roster of 19 restaurants, ranging from '50s diner to upscale Italian. Gift cards can be redeemed at all of our restaurants for dine-in visits or call-in carryout orders, and they never expire.
$75 Gift Card
Food Fight is a locally-owned restaurant group with a diverse roster of 19 restaurants, ranging from '50s diner to upscale Italian. Gift cards can be redeemed at all of our restaurants for dine-in visits or call-in carryout orders, and they never expire.
$100 Gift Card
Food Fight is a locally-owned restaurant group with a diverse roster of 19 restaurants, ranging from '50s diner to upscale Italian. Gift cards can be redeemed at all of our restaurants for dine-in visits or call-in carryout orders, and they never expire.
$150 Gift Card
Food Fight is a locally-owned restaurant group with a diverse roster of 19 restaurants, ranging from '50s diner to upscale Italian. Gift cards can be redeemed at all of our restaurants for dine-in visits or call-in carryout orders, and they never expire.
$200 Gift Card
Food Fight is a locally-owned restaurant group with a diverse roster of 19 restaurants, ranging from '50s diner to upscale Italian. Gift cards can be redeemed at all of our restaurants for dine-in visits or call-in carryout orders, and they never expire.

Appetizers
Bacon Au Poivre
Beef Tartare
Calamari
Candied Squash
Crab Cakes
Croquettes
FFAH Ceviche
Shrimp Cocktail
Stuffed Mushrooms
Tuna Tartare

Soup/Salad
Caesar
Crab Louie Salad
French Onion
Lobster Bisque
Spinach Salad
Tenderloin Caesar
Wedge Salad

Steaks
6 oz Filet
Served with demi-glace and brushed with herb compound butter. Choice of garlic mashed potatoes, baked potato (with sour cream and chives) or hash browns. Steaks with enhancements will not be served with demi-glace.
A5 Wagyu
10 oz Filet
12 oz New York Strip
14 oz New York Strip
16 oz Ribeye
20 oz Ribeye
10 oz Sirloin

Entree
Lamb
French Dip
Mac and Cheese Entree
Gnocchi
1/2 Gnocchi
Scallops
Chicken
1# Crab Legs
1/2# Crab Legs
Burger Du Jour
Tenderloin Sandwich
Lobster Roll
Lobster Tail
Roasted Halibut
Dover Sole
Scottish Salmon
Scallops Entree
Tenderloin Caesar

Sides
Grilled Asparagus
Brussels Sprouts
House Cut Fries
Mac and Cheese
Mushroom Risotto
Onion Straws
Mush and Onions
Mushrooms
Onions
Baked Potato
Potato Royale
Garlic Mashed
Hash Brown
Wild Rice Pilaf
Au Poivre Sauce
Bearnaise
Bordelaise
Creamy Horseradish
Bone Marrow
Soy-Black Garlic Butter
Truffle Butter
Bread and butter to go

Dessert
Cheesecake
Chocolate Sponge Roll
Creme Brulee
Ice cream
Panna Cotta
Party Choc Torte
FFAH Panna Cotta
Sorbet

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+75 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+74 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

We had ordered a $78 ribeye, med rare. It was over cooked, even cutting through the middle as the waitress asked. Even though it was not cooked to our request, she said, is it good enough in a way we felt bad about having another recooked. I was disappointed that the bill was not offered discount as a good will offering considering we tried to be flexible.
June 2025
I wanted to love this place due to my brother’s recommendation and it being a celebratory dinner. However, Delmonico’s has left something to be desired.

The Good:
-Our waitress was excellent and on top of everything.
-The hash brown was my favorite part of the meal and I encourage anyone to try it.
- The Delmonico Old Fashioned was a nice take on a classic and was enjoyable.

The Bad:
- I ordered the...
October 2024
Our wait stuff was very nice and accommodating! The steaks was prepared perfectly! Definitely will be back again!

Parking: Johnny Delmonico's is one of our favorite places to go out for supper! If you are looking for wait staff that goes above and beyond as well as great food check them out! Never been disappointed in our numerous times going there :)
October 2024

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Marigold Kitchen - 118 S Pinckney St
American, Cafe, Vegan, Vegetarian
Settle Down Tavern - 117 S Pinckney St
Hamburger, Bar, Burgers, American, Pet Friendly
Merchant Madison - 121 S Pinckney St
American, Cocktail Bar, Wine Bar, Pet Friendly, New American

Johnny Delmonico's Steakhouse

130 S Pinckney St, Madison, WI 53703
(608) 230-5800