Mariner’s Inn
5339 Lighthouse Bay Dr, Madison
(608) 246-3120
Customers' Favorites
Seafood Stuffed Mushrooms
Tenderloin Medallions
Giant Shrimp Plate
Salmon Florentine
Chocolate Mousse
Shrimp Cocktail
Prawn Cocktail
Bone-In Ribeye
Surf and Turf
Cheese Curds
Menu
Photos
+83 photos
+82 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We enjoyed our dinner here. We had originally made our reservation for outside seating. When we arrived we found out they had closed this due to heat. That was a bummer but we still enjoyed. Recommend making a reservation. We sat outside while we waited for our food. We were told\nTo follow the path along building which was by the overflowing dumpsters. Not a great first impression but thankfully once seated food was very good. We all loved our food and drinks. Our waitress did...
The waitress was really nice, and we were seated quickly. The menu for seafood limited. They are supposed to be known for their steaks but their pricing was more for a steakhouse. When they say they’ve been around since ‘66, nothing looks like it has changed since then. This is not lakeside dining. Felt more like stuff put together not cooking. Not bad, but not good. Certainly not like the photos.
The waitress was really nice, and we were seated quickly. The menu for seafood limited. They are supposed to be known for their steaks but their pricing was more for a steakhouse. When they say they've been around since ‘66, nothing looks like it has changed since then. This is not lakeside dining. Felt more like stuff put together not cooking. Not bad, but not good.
You May Also Like
Murphy's Bar and Restaurant - 5344 WI-113
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Pubs, Vegetarian
Athens Grill of Westport - 5430 Willow Rd
![]()
Greek, Mediterranean, Bar, Vegetarian
Willows Tavern - 5485 Willow Rd
![]()
Bar, American