Toby's Supper Club
3717 S Dutch Mill Rd, Madison
(608) 222-6913
Customers' Favorites
Sirloin Steak Special
Perch and Blue Gills
Breaded Cheese Curds
Loaded Baked Potato
Top Sirloin Steak
Pan Fried Chicken
Lake Perch Dinner
Fried Lake Perch
Toby's Special
Cinnamon Roll
Menu
Photos
+54 photos
+53 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
You need more than two restrooms. The food was really good and the key lime pie martini is amazing, but alcohol and only two bathrooms in an extremely crowded setting is not a good idea. We had to wait 20 minutes to use the one female restroom and two hours to eat.
This is the best Wisconsin supper club. Hands down. If you haven't gone here then you're missing the boat. This is fabulous food. Fabulous people. Great atmosphere and what Wisconsin is all about. I would recommend this to anybody anytime
Hubby and I took a quick get away to Madison, and of course we wanted to eat at a Wisconsin supper club. Found Tobys, read the reviews, and decided to give it a go. The reviews left us a little confused as to how their system works, but a phone call and early arrival time worked in our favor. Shortly after their opening at 3:00 pm, we found a place at the bar, ordered a couple of old fashions and a plate of appetizers (we hadn't eaten all day), and that, along with chatty...
You May Also Like
Arby's - 4 Collins Ct
![]()
Fast Food
Dutch Mill Sports Club - 4818 Dutch Mill Rd #4112
![]()
Bar & Grill, Sports Bar, Karaoke
Rusty Dog Coffee LLC - no public hours, 3244 Progress Rd
![]()
Coffee Roasteries