Pop's Frozen Custard
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
N87W16459 Appleton Ave, Menomonee Falls
(262) 251-3320
About Pop's Frozen Custard
Pop's Frozen Custard Reviews
Amazing place. Great food. Great service. Delicious custard. So many memories. Am heartbroken hearing it will be closing.
Best Custard in Milwaukee area and most original flavors I have seen anywhere.
Best Custard in Milwaukee area and most original flavors I have seen anywhere.
Menu
People in Menomonee Falls Also Viewed
Pop's Frozen Custard is a quaint eatery in Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin, serving delectable frozen custard, juicy burgers, scrumptious sandwiches, and heavenly malts. The shop is known for its mouth-watering options and offers a variety of food choices, including the Hot Ham & Swiss sub, jumbo cheeseburger, and mini corn dogs. While wheelchair accessibility is limited due to a narrow hallway to the bathroom, the owners are polite and helpful if there are any issues with orders. The custard is considered the best tasting in the metro Milwaukee area, using the same formula since 1981, with exciting flavors including homemade brownies. The place has a nice atmosphere, not overly busy, with many sundae options available. Customers have noted the friendly and prompt service, though caution is advised with some outdoor plastic chairs.