The Alumni Club Tavern & Eatery

Had a fantastic Mothers Day Brunch Meal! I tried their Irish Benedict and it was amazing! The bloody's are always delicious. Tried the famous bacon. Great twist of sweet and spicy.

So disappointed in this place. They apparently think it is ok for their employees to rip customers off. My husband & I stopped in for dinner on March 29. Afterward we played some of their gambling machines. I won $601! I gave my ticket to Harvey who told me he couldn’t pay me & I would have to come back. OK, no problem. Before we left, I had another ticket for $100. I gave it to my husband to cash with Harvey while I went to the restroom. Harvey said he couldn’t pay this out either & would add to the envelope. Next day they had an event & my daughter was there so I asked her to pick up the money. Only $601 in the envelope. My daughter saw Harvey on Thurs April 3 & asked him about it. He told her he had paid my husband. Absolutely did not happen. On Sat April 5, we went in the morning & I asked to speak with a manager & spoke with Christina. She told me that $100 ticket was in there but when she questioned Harvey about the $100 ticket, he claimed it was already paid out, he also claimed that Arianna paid me. Not true & she wasn’t even there any longer. Christina told me that if she would have paid this out, she would have been $100 short. Now I don’t know who got that $100 but it certainly wasn’t us. Christina told me she would check it out & call me the next day. Never got a call. Saw her on Mon & she seemed quite uncomfortable & said the owner was supposed to call me. Again, never got a call. Tues, April 8, I sent an email through their website. It states you will receive a response in 48 hours. Guess what, no response.

Great specials. Tends to get packed at dinner time on Friday Fish Fry but they do have an overflow room downstairs.

The staff is friendly, I really enjoy the few things that I have eaten.

We've been here many times.but we were just there Thursday and ordered a large pizza which literally had about 10 olives 10 mushrooms and about 10 pieces of sausage on it very disappointed.were afraid to give back and try again.

We stopped in for wings, salad and a couple of mixed drinks and it was a good experience. The wing sauce choices were really nice!

Bartender was extremly rude when I (over 21) entered the bar at 5:30 pm to eat dinner

Best bar in the city!

So enjoy the Alumni Club in Menomonee

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Fish Fry

I have been coming here for two years. Absolutely best customer service. Excellent bartender Christina. Friendly & skilled as a bartender. The cook Jaime is an excellent cook & always helping everyone. Recommend this place to everyone.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Italian, Fish Fry

Christina and Jaime ate awesome, always friendly, professional, and courteous. We love coming here! Best breakfast!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My BLT was extremely dry with the bacon having absolutely no taste but the French fries were amazing! Service was good but the music is WAY too loud and you can't even have a conversation.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 5

My BLT was extremely dry with the bacon having absolutely no taste but the French fries were amazing! Service was good but the music is WAY too loud and you can't even have a conversation.

Food was delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Burger

Great food and friendly people

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5