Mr. Dye's Pies
275 W Wisconsin Ave, Milwaukee
(414) 759-4992
Customers' Favorites
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Key Lime Pie
Pumpkin Pie
Pecan Pie
Apple Pie
Perogi
Menu
Photos
+40 photos
+39 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I visited Mr. Dye's Pies today and I just had to show my appreciation for not only the pies but the wonderful and personable customer service!! The gentleman who offered me a sample of the Purple Monster pie was so kind and I hands down had to buy a slice after my first bite! Similar to Sweet Potato Pie but purple and I definitely recommend it as a MUST when visiting. Key Lime Pie is also my favorite and it was perfectly tart. My only wish was to have added whip cream but...
Grabbed a 1/2 Gluten Free Key Lime Pie at the Madison Farmers market last weekend. It’s hard to find GF pies and this one did not disappoint! The crust was equally crisp and crumbly like Graham cracker crust should be. The filling was perfectly tart. Just like my grandma made down in the Florida keys!
It is my husband's birthday and our first time trying Mr Dye's Pies. Ronnie waited on us and was very friendly. We bought slices of different kinds and had to go back for more. The banana bread we bought(not pictured) is delicious too. Did I mention we bought the savory Pies as well? 3rd Street Market y'all. Go find and buy Mr Dye's pies!😋
You May Also Like
Mr. Wings Milwaukee - 275 W Wisconsin Ave Suite 100
![]()
Chicken Wings, Pubs
Smokin’ Jack's BBQ (3rd St. Market Hall) - 275 W Wisconsin Ave
![]()
Barbecue, Barbeque