Peter Sciortino Bakery
1101 E Brady St, Milwaukee
(414) 272-4623
Customers' Favorites
Black Forest Cherry Torte
Pecan Finger - Per Pound
Monterosa Cheesecake
Italian Rainbow Cake
Peanut Butter Cookie
Chocolate Croissant
Christmas Cookies
Hot Ham and Rolls
Almond Croissant
Holiday Cookies
Menu
Photos
+52 photos
+51 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We were visiting from St. Louis and were told that Brady Street featured a lot of ethnic shops/food and we came upon this bakery. SO many choices; everything looked delicious and was presented so nicely. My friend got a rainbow cookie and I got a lemon cookie dusted with powdered sugar. SO good! We came back a little bit later and got two more rainbow cookies. It reminded me of the cookies my great aunt from Palermo made when we were kids.
The moment you walk in, the display cases are absolutely stunning — rows of pastries and cookies that make you want to try every single one. They even had unique cookies I’d never seen before but instantly wanted to taste. It’s definitely the kind of bakery you’ll want to come back to again and again just to sample something new each time. We tried a mini cannoli with cream and cherries, and I’ve honestly never had a cannoli like that before — it was one of the best...
Kind of an odd experience. I ordered ham and rolls on Sunday and asked for the ham shaved, but was eventually told they don’t do shaved hot ham “because otherwise it would be like soup.” WHAT!? There’s a ton of other area bakeries that do and I’ve ordered it this way for years. I don’t know…they thought I was crazy I think. No onion rolls either. The staff was friendly and working hard. The ricotta cookies were delicious but crumbled very quickly unfortunately. I...
You May Also Like
Twisted Plants - 1233 E Brady St
![]()
Vegan, Burgers, Vegetarian
Pete's Pub - 1234 E Brady St
![]()
Pubs, American, Sports Bar, Burgers
Shawarma Palace - 1701 N Humboldt Ave
![]()
Middle Eastern, Mediterranean