Pizzeria Scotty
9022 W Oklahoma Ave, West Allis
(414) 543-1300
Customers' Favorites
Stuffed Pizza with Pepperoni Mushrooms Green Pepper and Onion
Deep Fried Garlic Bread Sticks
Chicago Style Vegetarian Pizza
Chicago Pan Cheese Pizza
Italian Beef Sandwich
Stuffed Cheese Pizza
Garlic Breadsticks
Mozzarella Sticks
Breaded Mushrooms
Thin Crust Pizza
Breaded Mushrooms
Breaded Mushroom Regular
Breaded Mushroom Half Tray
Breaded Mushroom Full Tray
Deep Fried Garlic Breadsticks
Deep Fried Garlic Breadsticks Regular
Deep Fried Garlic Breadsticks Half Tray
Deep Fried Garlic Breadsticks Full Tray
French Fries
French Fries Regular
French Fries Half Tray
French Fries Full Tray
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread Half Tray
Garlic Bread Full Tray
Mozz Sticks
Mozzarella Sticks Regular
Mozzarella Sticks Half Tray
Mozzarella Sticks Full Tray
Build Your Own
10 Inch Build Your Own
10 Inch Gluten Free
12 Inch Build Your Own
14 Inch Build Your Own
16 Inch Build Your Own
Buffalo Chicken Deluxe
10 Inch Buffalo
authentic buffalo wing sauce LOADED with chunks of zesty fajita chicken, smothered with mozzarella & mild cheddar, then topped with premium bleu cheese crumbles
12 Inch Buffalo
authentic buffalo wing sauce LOADED with chunks of zesty fajita chicken, smothered with mozzarella & mild cheddar, then topped with premium bleu cheese crumbles
14 Inch Buffalo
authentic buffalo wing sauce LOADED with chunks of zesty fajita chicken, smothered with mozzarella & mild cheddar, then topped with premium bleu cheese crumbles
16 Inch Buffalo
authentic buffalo wing sauce LOADED with chunks of zesty fajita chicken, smothered with mozzarella & mild cheddar, then topped with premium bleu cheese crumbles
Ultimate 5 Cheese
10 Inch U5
Not a meat eater? try this perfect blend of monterey jack, mild cheddar, mozzarella & grated romano cheese topped with premium bleu cheese. Outstanding!
12 Inch U5
Not a meat eater? try this perfect blend of monterey jack, mild cheddar, mozzarella & grated romano cheese topped with premium bleu cheese. Outstanding!
14 Inch U5
Not a meat eater? try this perfect blend of monterey jack, mild cheddar, mozzarella & grated romano cheese topped with premium bleu cheese. Outstanding!
16 Inch U5
Not a meat eater? try this perfect blend of monterey jack, mild cheddar, mozzarella & grated romano cheese topped with premium bleu cheese. Outstanding!
Sausage Supreme
10 Inch Sausage Supreme
sausage, onion, green pepper & mushroom
12 Inch Sausage Supreme
sausage, onion, green pepper & mushroom
14 Inch Sausage Supreme
sausage, onion, green pepper & mushroom
16 Inch Sausage Supreme
sausage, onion, green pepper & mushroom
Vegetarian Deluxe
10 Inch Veggie
mushrooms, onions, green peppers & mushroom
12 Inch Veggie
mushrooms, onions, green peppers & mushroom
14 Inch Veggie
mushrooms, onions, green peppers & mushroom
16 Inch Veggie
mushrooms, onions, green peppers & mushroom
Pepperoni Supreme
10 Inch Pepperoni Supreme
pepperoni, onions, green peppers & mushroom
12 Inch Pepperoni Supreme
pepperoni, onions, green peppers & mushroom
14 Inch Pepperoni Supreme
pepperoni, onions, green peppers & mushroom
16 Inch Pepperoni Supreme
pepperoni, onions, green peppers & mushroom
BBQ Chicken Deluxe
10 Inch BBQ Chicken
white meat chicken, bbq sauce, mozzarella, red onions & tomatoes, topped with cheddar/jack cheese
12 Inch BBQ Chicken
white meat chicken, bbq sauce, mozzarella, red onions & tomatoes, topped with cheddar/jack cheese
14 Inch BBQ Chicken
white meat chicken, bbq sauce, mozzarella, red onions & tomatoes, topped with cheddar/jack cheese
16 Inch BBQ Chicken
white meat chicken, bbq sauce, mozzarella, red onions & tomatoes, topped with cheddar/jack cheese
Ranch Style Bacon & Chicken Supreme
10 Inch Ranch Style
premium ranch dressing, LOADED with chunks of juicy fajita chicken & primed with real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese. All this veiled with a manly portion of real bacon!
12 Inch Ranch Style
premium ranch dressing, LOADED with chunks of juicy fajita chicken & primed with real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese. All this veiled with a manly portion of real bacon!
14 Inch Ranch Style
premium ranch dressing, LOADED with chunks of juicy fajita chicken & primed with real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese. All this veiled with a manly portion of real bacon!
16 Inch Ranch Style
premium ranch dressing, LOADED with chunks of juicy fajita chicken & primed with real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese. All this veiled with a manly portion of real bacon!
Scotty Extreme
10 Inch Extreme
Not for the faint of heart! a robust blend of italian sausage, canadian bacon, ground beef, pepperoni, bacon, fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sliced tomatoes, black & green olives. This creation is sure to overwhelm your hunger with each flavorful bite!
12 Inch Extreme
Not for the faint of heart! a robust blend of italian sausage, canadian bacon, ground beef, pepperoni, bacon, fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sliced tomatoes, black & green olives. This creation is sure to overwhelm your hunger with each flavorful bite!
14 Inch Extreme
Not for the faint of heart! a robust blend of italian sausage, canadian bacon, ground beef, pepperoni, bacon, fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sliced tomatoes, black & green olives. This creation is sure to overwhelm your hunger with each flavorful bite!
16 Inch Extreme
Not for the faint of heart! a robust blend of italian sausage, canadian bacon, ground beef, pepperoni, bacon, fresh mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sliced tomatoes, black & green olives. This creation is sure to overwhelm your hunger with each flavorful bite!
Deep Fried Garlic Breadsticks
Deep Fried Garlic Breadsticks Regular
Deep Fried Garlic Breadsticks Half Tray
Deep Fried Garlic Breadsticks Full Tray
Mozzarella Sticks
Mozzarella Sticks Regular
Mozzarella Sticks Half Tray
Mozzarella Sticks Full Tray
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread
Garlic Bread Half Tray
Garlic Bread Full Tray
French Fries
French Fries Regular
French Fries Half Tray
French Fries Full Tray
Breaded Mushrooms
Breaded Mushroom Regular
Breaded Mushroom Half Tray
Breaded Mushroom Full Tray
Boneless Wings
Boneless Wings Regular
Boneless Wings Pound
Boneless Wings Half Tray
Boneless Wings Full Tray
Regular Wings
Regular Wings Regular
Regular 12 Wings
Regular Wings Half Tray
Regular Wings Full Tray
Scotty Sticks
10 Inch Scotty Stick
Served with your choice of ranch, bleu cheese, bbq or buffalo sauce. Add toppings at menu price.
12 Inch Scotty Stick
Served with your choice of ranch, bleu cheese, bbq or buffalo sauce. Add toppings at menu price.
14 Inch Scotty Stick
Served with your choice of ranch, bleu cheese, bbq or buffalo sauce. Add toppings at menu price.
16 Inch Scotty Stick
Served with your choice of ranch, bleu cheese, bbq or buffalo sauce. Add toppings at menu price.
Sandwiches
The "Big Cheese"
one-third pound of delicious, thin sliced italian beef served on french bread smothered with melted mozzarella
Italian Beef
Meatball Sandwich
Pizza Bread
Mostaccioli
Mostaccioli Regular
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.
Mostaccioli Half Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.
Mostaccioli Full Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.
Ravioli
Cheese Ravioli Regular
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.
Cheese Ravioli Half Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.
Cheese Ravioli Full Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.
Baked Lasagna
Baked Lasagna Regular
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.
Baked Lasagna Half Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.
Baked Lasagna Full Tray
A generous portion of pasta with homemade marinara served with coleslaw, french bread & grated romano cheese.
Garden
Garden Salad Regular
Crispy romaine, carrots, red cabbage, tomatoes & red onions
Garden Salad Half Tray
Crispy romaine, carrots, red cabbage, tomatoes & red onions
Garden Salad Full Tray
Crispy romaine, carrots, red cabbage, tomatoes & red onions
Caesar
Caesar Salad Regular
crispy romaine, croutons, parmesan cheese, served with a creamy caesar dressing
Caesar Salad Half Tray
crispy romaine, croutons, parmesan cheese, served with a creamy caesar dressing
Caesar Salad Full Tray
crispy romaine, croutons, parmesan cheese, served with a creamy caesar dressing
Side Orders
Beef Juice
Marinara Sauce
Pizza Sauce
Hot Peppers
Sweet Peppers
Meatballs (3)
Anchovies
Coleslaw
French Bread
Side Buffalo
Hot Giardiniera
Pepperoncini
Side BBQ
Side Ranch
Side Blue Cheese Dressing
Beverages
Can Pepsi
Can Diet Pepsi
Can Mountain Dew
Bottle Water
2-Liter Pepsi
2-Liter Diet Pepsi
2-Liter Mountain Dew
6-Pack Pepsi
6-Pack Diet Pepsi
6-Pack Mt. Dew
6-Pack Water
Photos
+32 photos
+31 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Great atmosphere. Service is always smiling and chatting you up. Pizza awesome, tried the wings, deep fried mushrooms, and deep fried garlic bread all were amazing. One of the best place in town.
November 2025
We live close by and walked over to place our order for the fun of it instead of calling. The staff was super helpful and nice; we ordered the Wednesday special and got a stuffed cheese pizza with breadsticks. Honestly, both were so delicious!
We will certainly be returning! What an awesome pizzeria.
We will certainly be returning! What an awesome pizzeria.
October 2025
I recently tried their stuffed pizza. We got a small and after one piece I was stuffed myself lol. It's a cute little place and I'm guessing it was the owner who helped me, but whoever the older gentleman was that helped me was awesome. He was super friendly and polite. It's on the pricier side but the food is delicious and will feed u for 2 days so it's worth it.
October 2025
You May Also Like
Caterina's Ristorante - 9104 W Oklahoma Ave
![]()
Italian, Vegan
Subway - 9115 W Oklahoma Ave Unit B
![]()
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
George Webb Restaurant - 3133 S 92nd St
![]()
American, Burgers