Reynold's Pasty Shop

$ •

3525 W Burleigh St, Milwaukee
(414) 444-4490


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for Reynold's Pasty Shop

Always excellent food, excellent service. Staff is wonderful and friendly and they keep this Milwaukee staple alive. I'm glad prices are still perfectly affordable and our beloved Pasties are still hearty and delicious! Many thanks to the staff for continuing to put out great food and keep this place alive.

The pasty is far too bland, the overriding flavor is black pepper, of which there is too much. The box said there was salt in it. I couldn't taste it at all. More appropriate seasonings are badly needed. There also needs to be more vegetables in the pasty besides potatoes and a sliver of a carrot. The meat is far too greasy and difficult to swallow for that reason. Do you have a vegetarian version that would be better seasoned and less greasy? The one I had cried out full review

Still the best. Hot tasty pasty's ready to go. The pastry is so good and crispy, and the meat and potato mix is so good and hot. Still under 5$ a pop, you can add a drink, gravy, cheese sauce for a little more. This is a small takeout place, no tables. The place is small and so is the menu. But the food is delicious, as generations of milwaukeans can attest to: Reynolds has been here since the 50s. It's really good food, go try it if you haven't. Cash is best here.

More Reviews(27)


Monday Closed
Tuesday 9:30AM - 6:30PM
Wednesday 9:30AM - 6:30PM
Thursday 9:30AM - 6:30PM
Friday 9:30AM - 6:30PM
Saturday 9:30AM - 6:30PM
Sunday Closed

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.